Helen Rayner, M.P.H., Susan Lovelle Allen, M.D.2 and Eric R. Braverman,
M.D.
Abstract
A review of the literature reveals that unfavourable surgical
outcome, including problems with wound infection and dehiscence,
sepsis, and longer lengths of stay, correlates well with the determination
of perioperative malnutrition as measured by a variety of indices.
Increased malnutrition and more severe surgeries are individually
predictive of poorer outcome. There is evidence that particular
deficiencies of nutrients are likely to cause wound healing problems.
Particularly important nutrients include amino acids (notably
glycine, proline, and arginine) carbohydrates, fatty acids (especially
linoleic and linolenic), vitamins (particularly C and A), minerals
and the elements (particularly magnesium, copper, phosphorous
and selenium).
The postoperative feeding of seemingly large amounts of amino
acids is correlated with positive nitrogen balance and shorter
hospital stays. The enteral route is preferred unless there is
disturbed absorption or other complications, Total parenteral
nutrition (TPN) formulations should include all of the essential
nutrients, especially trace elements which were formerly overlooked.
Introduction
With surgery, as with trauma and sepsis, there is an increase
in the requirement for calories, amino acids, vitamins, minerals,
water and oxygen. This paper reviews the possible relationship
between certain nutrients and wound healing, evidence pointing
to a connection between perioperative nutritional status and surgical
outcome (including wound healing), and information concerning
route of administration and prevention of deficiencies of certain
nutrients.
Nutrients Which May Affect Wound Healing
"Wound healing is a biochemical process and that nutrition itself
is really a clinical biochemistry, and an obvious relationship
between these two areas exists ... Nutrition has to be thought
of by all clinicians as the specific nutrient substrates that
are being delivered to the specific cells and tissues at a given
time. This is where nutrition really occurs, at the cell membrane
and in the cell, and it is only when we realize this and practice
surgery with this in the proper context that we will then achieve
optimal wound healing to correlate with the technical and other
aspects of wound healing in which we engage as surgeons."' H.
Polk
Protein and Amino Acid Balance
Surgery, trauma and sepsis introduce a protein catabolic state.2
Wound healing is in part dependent on the ability of the body
to provide adequate amounts of amino acids. Animal studies conducted
by Harvey and Gibson showed that simultaneous supplementation
with glycine, proline and arginine produced an increase of as
much as 60-70% in nitrogen retained.3 This effect may be reversed
if glycine alone is used.4
Arginine, which can be converted to proline is associated with
more rapid wound healing and greater collagen synthesis in animal
models and may ever inhibit post-trauma weight loss.5,6 Furthermore,
arginine-deficient rats rapidly lost collagen.5 Glycine accounts
for approximately one-third of all amino acid: found in most collagen
alpha chains. Glycine and arginine are shown to be necessary for
the synthesis of creatinine, and for optimal growth in experimental
animals.5 Furthermore, arginine detoxifies ammonia and detoxifies
benzoic acid. Glycine may play a part in the repair of muscle
fibers.4 Arginine converts to ornithine glutamic semialdehyde
and proline, leading to proline's conversion to collagen. Arginine
can also be converted to lysine.4 There are about 200 proline
residues and thirty-five lysine residues in the alpha collagen
strands!
Hypoalbuminism has been associated with impaired healing of forearm
wounds in adults.8 It is thought that the lower plasma albumin
levels often observed following injury relate to slowed synthesis
and increased deposition at wound sites. (An increase in absolute
catabolism of albumin is not observed.9) Plasma albumin is thought
to act as an amino acid donor at wound sites and as a transporter
of zinc, fatty acids, and sulfur-containing amino acids."
Research suggests that nitrogen is more likely to be pulled from
muscle tissue in surgical stress and the liver is likely to be
spared.9 Even the early stages of protein-caloric malnutrition
have been correlated with impaired wound healing not unlike that
of advanced malnutrition. 26 There is some evidence that slow
scar formation in humans nevertheless results in normal scar tissue."
Carbohydrates and Fats
Fatty acids are essential for the transport of substances across
cell membranes. The optimal level of fat consumption for wound
healing has not been determined but 20% or more is common in hospitals.
Moderate liquid levels can reduce the potential hypoglycemic effect
of high glucose feeding. A deficiency in essential fatty acids
is associated with poor wound healing.12 However, an experiment
involving over 30% fat in a total parenteral formula yielded very
unsatisfactory postsurgical results. It was thought that the fat
inhibited the movement of leukocytes which are essential for the
prevention of sepsis and stimulation of scar tissue formation.13
Both carbohydrates and fats are important in that they provide
calories, have a protein sparing effect and provide energy. Generally,
it is necessary to use combinations of energy sources and proteins/amino
acids in order to preserve or augment nitrogen balance. If less
than caloric need of carbohydrate/lipid is given, it is also difficult
to achieve positive nitrogen balance.14 Usually carbohydrates
provide the bulk of calories for perioperative patients regardless
of route.
Water
Subcutaneous tissue is highly influenced by vasoconstriction and
can be poorly hydrated while the brain, liver, heart and kidney
are well perfused. Studies show that dehydration is associated
with low tissue P02 and increased catabolism.15 Such patients
are considered to be more susceptible to infection. One might
postulate that supplies of other essential nutrients to wounds
would be impaired as well by dehydration. When dialysis and heavy
loads of water are used, the purity of water (i.e. low levels
of aluminum and lead) is essential.
Oxygen
Subcutaneous hypoxia can be found in 33 to 80% of postoperative
patients.15 Most cases can be returned to normal tissue oxygen
levels through vigorous hydration efforts and administration of
a higher % of oxygen. Medicine needs an easy, accurate way to
measure tissue oxygen. Until this exists, aggressive measures
to ensure hydration are essential to safeguard against hypoxia.13
A state of slight hyperoxia (obtainable usually with either normobaric
or hyperbaric oxygen administration) can increase leukocyte bacterial-killing
activity. This effect will be additive when done in conjunction
with antibiotics. Hyperbaric oxygen treatment raising arterial
P02 to over 1,000 2,000 mm Hg for I hour per day may be adequate
to stimulate effective leukocyte bacterial killing. (Surgical
manipulation of blood supply can also be used to create hyperoxia.15)
Davis cites studies that showed that ischemia lowers local immunity
and that, in one study, infections were found only in subjects
with tissue P02 below 30 to 40 tort. Low pO2 can result in poorly
hydroxylated collagen which has less thermal stability.7
Vitamins, Minerals and Wound Healing
Vitamins are essential for wound healing. Gerber found increased
tensile strength in the wounds of rats fed supplemental retinyl
acetate, beta-carotene, or retinoic acid (all forms are precursors
of vitamin A) with measurably stronger scar tissue.16 Vitamin
A has also been shown to have a beneficial effect on the healing
of colonic anastomoses.17 Additionally, the increased risk of
anastomotic breakdown, leakages, and spontaneous perforations
seen both early and late after radiotherapy may be ameliorated
by vitamin A therapy with significant mitigation of the decreased
bursting strength and hydroxyproline content of the tissues which
is seen after radiotherapy.18,19,20
Of interest, an actual deficiency of vitamin A may not be required
for impaired wound healing. Niu reported increased hydroxyproline
content at the site of arterial anastomoses and increased bursting
strength at distant sites in rats supplemented with moderate levels
of vitamin A over that seen in controls who were themselves on
diets several times the National Research Council's RDA.20
Topical vitamin A appears also to have its uses; it may reverse
the inhibitory effect of steroids on healing wounds perhaps by
affecting leukocyte numbers involved in the inflammatory and wound
healing process.19
Vitamin A can restore epithelialization in the presence of glucocorticoids
which would otherwise suppress macrophage activity and hence wound
healing. It cannot, however, overcome the suppressive effect of
glucocorticoids on wound contraction.21
Vitamin E is a free-radical scavenger which preserves macrophages
and polynuclear leukocytes from the lipid peroxides that they
make.22 However, if a vitamin E deficiency exists, there may be
some impairment of wound healing. 13
Vitamin C is an essential co-factor in the formation of collagen.17
One of the symptoms of scurvy is the weakening and dehiscence
of old wounds.23 Decreased tensile strength was found in the excised
wounds of skin and facia lata in subjects deficient in vitamin
C.13 In a double-blind study, vitamin C 500 mg with meals and
at bedtime produced a decrease of 43% versus 84% in patients with
decubitus ulcers.26
The authors feel one striking anecdote concerning vitamin C and
wound healing deserves telling. In a panel discussion by leading
surgeons, one participant spoke of treating a cancer patient's
infected maxillary wound in the pre-antibiotic era with vitamin
C. He stated, "I had read that in an individual who has infection,
vitamin C is depleted, and although this man had no evidence of
scurvy, I thought it might be a case of sub-clinical scurvy, so
I gave him what I thought at that time was an enormous quantity
of vitamin C, 1000 mg a day, and immediately the wound began to
heal and the infection was controlled, and he got well, so this
made an impression upon me.""
Thiamine deficiency interferes with collagen synthesis; granulation
tissue was one-fifth normal in thiamine-deficient rats.24 Pantothenic
acid may accelerate the wound healing process; when 20 mg/kg/
day was given to rabbits, aponeurotic strength and number of fibroblasts
increased.25 Riboflavin is identified as an important mediator
of wound healing.9
Zinc is a mineral which is important for the action of collagenase,
the enzyme which breaks down collagen.4 Since 25% or more of the
collagen formed in the first week of wound healing is normally
broken down,27 the importance of zinc can be inferred for the
remodeling and strengthening of surgical wounds. One author suggests,
however, that significant depletion of zinc stores must exist
before it is an issue. Zinc metalloenzymes include DNA polymerase,
superoxide dismutase and reverse transcriptase. Zinc is depleted
by stress and suppressed by the influence of ACTH and anabolic
steroids which are elevated in the post-surgical patient.22 Achieving
the right balance is the issue. Pories and others found in 1967
that zinc sulfate given orally accelerated wound healing in one
patient. Furthermore, Pories and colleagues found that zinc was
important to the rapid reduction of wound cavity in excision of
pilonidal cysts.23
Zinc will reduce copper stores if used in excess. Copper is also
essential to proper wound healing as it is a co-factor for the
action of lysyl amine oxidase (LAO) in the aldehyde reactions
which generate strong covalent bonds in collagen.7,28 Selenium
is also considered important for wound healing. Manganese is necessary
for the glycosylation of hydroxyproline residues in the formation
of collagen.7
Effects of Nutritional Status on Surgical Outcome and Wound Healing
It would be difficult to prove without a doubt that strong wounds
are formed by providing adequate nutrition to patients or that
they form faster. Most wound research involving tensile or bursting
strength or even speed of wound healing has been done with animals
and there are problems in assuming rat or guinea pig wound healing
physiology sufficiently parallels that of humans.
Most of the evidence that nutritional Status plays an important
role in wound healing in humans is more indirect. There are many
studies correlating nutritional status (pre- and/or post-operative)
to surgical outcome (e.g., number of complications such as ruptured
anastomoses, dehiscence, infection, sepsis and length of stay).
Evaluating Patients At Risk
The prevalence of some degree of malnutrition (protein-calorie
and/or vitamin deficiency) is high among medical and/or surgical
patients. Buzby reviewed three studies and concluded that about
50% had some degree of protein-calorie malnutrition, regardless
of medical specialty or socicieconomic background.29 A table
summarizing such epidemiologic surveys shows 30% to be the lowest
rate among major surgery patients with 45-50% the most common
rate of protein-calorie malnutrition. Hypovitaminemia was found
in 50% of medical and surgical patients at one New Jersey hospital.50
Fortunately, serious malnutrition is found less frequently. Severity
of complications correlate with the degree of malnutrition and
with the seriousness of surgery.30 The surgeon must take into
account the type and extent of surgery to be performed in evaluating
risk.
It is estimated that surgical patients lose 4-8 % of their body
weight for minor surgery and 15-25% for major surgery.31 Experts
advocate taking a very careful nutritional history for all surgical
patients, covering: weight loss and its time frame and possible
causes; dietary habits; surgical history; unorthodox diets, use
of medications, drugs or alcohol, food intolerance, functional
capacity of the gastrointestinal tract; the presence of fever,
tachycardia; catabolism; irritable bowel syndrome, or short bowel
syndrome. The physical examination can provide useful information
on anthropometric measurements, edema, muscle, wasting and the
various signs of deficiencies. Malnutrition is often accompanied
by CNS depression, lowered ventilatory drive and blood pressure,
bradycardia, achlorhydria, irritability, apathy, and inability
to concentrate.32 Growth hormone is depressed but thyrotrophic
and adrenotrophic are not. Objective criteria are used to determine
degree of malnutrition though few utilize all of these measurements:
secretary proteins (albumin, transferrin, prealbumin, retinal
binding protein), skeletal protein (24-hour urinary creatinine
divided by height), muscle degradation (urinary 3-methylhistidine),
and various anthropometric determinations (weight-for-height,
triceps skinfold, mid. arm circumference).32 Immunologic indications
(skin test reactivity. complement levels and total leukocyte counts),
metabolic profiles, and tests of critical organ function have
all been associated with nutritional status.39
Correlating Nutritional Status With Surgical Outcome
To review some of the early research, Dr. Radin and others at
the University of Pennsylvania produced a hypoproteinemic state
in dogs during the 1930's and observed retarded gastric emptying
times in animals which had gastroenterostomies. Moreover, there
were several wound breakages and he attributed this to delayed
fibroplasia.13 With human subjects, as early as 1936, Studley
showed an association between poor nutritional and surgical outcome,
describing how surgical risk increased eightfold (33.3 vs 3.5%)
in patients with benign chronic peptic ulcer disease who had lost
more than 20% of their body weight as compared with those who
had no loss.34 Controversy arose, however, over the implications
of this study, i.e., is this association causal and, consequently,
is perioperative nutritional supplementation warranted?29
Several other studies have answered in the affirmative. Muller
randomized 125 surgical patients for ten days to either a typical
hospital diet or total parenteral nutrition (TPN) preoperatively.
Those on TPN bad increased serum total protein, transferrin, albumin,
and immunoglobulins as well as skin test responsiveness. Postoperative
morbidity (intra-abdominal abscess, peritonitis, anastomotic leakage,
ileus) was decreased albeit not significantly; however, the number
of patients requiring artificial respiration was increased, again
not significantly.35
Mughal (1987) studied thirty-two patients with clinical and laboratory
evidence of malnutrition (serum albumin <3.5 and recent weight
loss > 10% plus any two of the following at or below the tenth
percentile: weight for height, midarm circumference, triceps skinfold.
They were found to have greater postoperative morbidity and mortality
when compared to their well-nourished counterparts. In addition,
if complications did occur, it took the malnourished patients
twice as long to achieve satisfactory oral intake.36
The Cardiff study was able to demonstrate a significant decrease
in the incidence of wound infections in those given parenteral
nutritional support (40% vs 83%).37 Gill and Mequid showed a correlation
between complications (poor wound healing, increased fatality
rates, longer hospitalization) and the severity of malnutrition
in major surgery.36,39 Hospital duration was decreased as much
as four to six days in two out of three studies of colorectal
surgery.40,41,42
Dudrick said in a panel discussion that he and colleagues from
The University of Texas Medical School (Houston) assessed ninety-six
patients who were to have elective hip surgery. Twenty percent
were found to be nutritionally deficient, especially in protein
status, when evaluated by fourteen indices. Protocol called for
surgery to be done as planned. One year later 18% had significant
complications (including infections and wobbling prostheses) and
all of these patients had been judged malnourished at the time
of surgery. Now they provide all such patients with one to three
weeks of a preoperative repletional program (including occasional
tube feeding) until normal nutritional status is regained.13 Dempsey
and Mullen surveyed eighty studies dealing with nutritional status
and surgical outcome. They point out that most (forty-five studies)
had insufficient data to determine usefulness in terms of sensitivity,
specificity and efficiency. The percentage of patients with poor
nutritional ratings who have poor outcomes ranged from 1% to 100%
with a mean of 65%. The positive predictive value (which is the
percentage of positive tests which are true indicators for outcome)
ranged from 1% to 83% with a mean of 37%. Finally, the efficiency
of nutritional predictors (or the ability of nutritional ratings
to predict either a good or poor outcome) ranged from 27% to 94%
with a mean of 68%. The conclusion of the paper is that more rigorous
research methodology is needed to evaluate the efficacy of nutritional
programs in improving surgical outcome.35 A review of the use
of nutritional indicators and concluded that predicting survival
is possible 80% of the time and death, 40% of the time. Use of
serial measurements (made every 10 to 14 days) allows one to predict
death accurately in 78% of all Cases.29,43
A set of simple predictive criteria used with elective surgery
and other patients at M.D. Anderson Hospital and Hermann Hospital
for several years is as follows: the patient is tested for three
criteria a low serum albumin (less than 3.4 g per dl), a low total
lymphocyte count, and recent inadvertent weight loss or more than
10% body weight. The presence of one indicator corresponds with
mild malnutrition, and rare wound disruption; two indicators correspond
with moderate malnutrition and a 4-6% rate of wound disruption;
three indicators are present in moderately severe to severe malnutrition
and are associated with a 14% wound disruption rate. A patient
who has lost 30% of their well weight in 30 to 60 days has a 30-50
% chance of wound dehiscence. Tissue edema is expected in patients
with serum protein below 5.5 g percent.13
The superiority of any one plasma protein or formula as a predictor
of surgical outcome is difficult to establish. Pomp and colleagues
have summarized the strengths and weaknesses of various nutritional
assessment tools.44,50 Significant underweight is an obvious and
definite health risk. Changes in transferrin correlated significantly
with changes in nitrogen balance (p =.02) but prealbumin did not
in a study by Fletcher.45 Transferrin may reduce the supply of
iron to invasive organisms."
Hill made a comparison of various studies and concluded that transferrin,
prealbumin and the "Leeds Formula" yielded the most significant
predictors. Changes in albumin are not rapid enough due to a long
half-life; therefore, it is not the best protein for tracking
patient progress. (It is Useful for predictive outcome at the
outset.) Simple determination of weight loss was quite specific
for poor surgical outcome as were the Philadelphia and Boston
formulas. The surgeon's assessment was 86% accurate for predicting
good outcome in the presence of malnutrition but only 27% accurate
for predicting a poor surgical outcome (positive predictive value).10
Buzby reports that patients having serum albumin levels of 2.6
g per dl or less have a less than 596 chance of survival. (Death
is usually by sepsis.) The 50% chance occurs at 3.2g per dl.29
Arise in serum prealbumin taken weekly has been shown by Church
and others to be predictive of positive nitrogen balance with
a sensitivity of 88%, specificity of 70%, positive predictive
value of 93% and negative predictive value of 56%. In cases of
death, dropping nitrogen balance W25 the best indicator. Of all
the plasma proteins, prealbumin was the best indicator of poor
outcome.46 However, some consider it to reflect dietary intake
more than nutritional status.44
Warnold found that malnourished non-cancer surgery patients (having
two or more abnormal values for % weight loss, body weight relative
to reference weight, mid-arm muscle circumference or serum albumin)
had an average length of stay of twenty-nine days versus fourteen
days for normally nourished surgical patients. The malnourished
group had a 31% rate of serious complications while the normals
had 9% (p <.05).47
Patients showing negative response to a set of recall antigens
in one study were later to have five times the normal rate of
infection and mortality. Therefore when anergy is detected, physicians
should assess nutritional risk carefully.48 Many alterations in
host immunity have been noted with malnutrition including decreased
intracellular bacterial killing, decreased C3 (which can in turn
decrease opsonic function if the level falls to 30%) and fewer
lymphocytes.48
Several formulas may be necessary to address all types of surgery.10
More research is needed to confirm that the observed correlations
are strictly nutritional. It is evident that nutritional status
has considerable effect on surgical outcome which includes wound
healing. Assumptions must be questioned. For example, there needs
to be a way to determine in what way feeding will improve the
surgical results or if the impact of the disease is mostly responsible
for the condition.49 Determination of the optimal nutritional
prognosticators of surgical outcome would help determine more
exactly how to do perioperative nutrition. Protein-calorie malnutrition
can occur in surgical and chronically ill patients. Predisposing
factors are many, including anorexia, malabsorption due to various
gastrointestinal disorders, hypermetabolism secondary to surgery,
fever, infection, inflammation, trauma, and abnormal nutrient
losses, e.g., after extensive burns.10
Perioperative Nutrition
Some considerations in providing perioperative nutrition are covered
in this section. It is beyond the scope of this paper to fully
describe the benefits and risks of enteral vs. parenteral feeding,
the types of feeding arrangements and possible formulas.
Method of Feeding
Briefly, it should be the principle of health care professionals
to use the oral route when possible, followed by nasogastric tube,
possibly jejunostomy or gastrostomy (for long-term use), then
IV feeding.10 Some feel a combination of enteral and peripheral
parenteral nutrition (PPN) is less invasive than central parenteral
nutrition (CPN).32 However, CPN is the route of choice in severe
malnutrition.
Enteral Feeding
Enteral feeding has the advantage of avoiding the accumulation
of excess water,50 encouraging crypt cell turnover and inhibiting
villous atrophy in the gut. The stimulation of hormonal secretion
may also have beneficial systemic effects. It is especially recommended
in protein-calorie malnutrition with severe sysphasia, inadequate
oral intake for the five successive days, massive small bowel
resection (using TPN as well), and with low output enter. ocutaneous
fistulas.51
Problems associated with enteral feeding include poor tolerance
in very ill patients, diarrhea, and gastrointestinal intolerance,
often due to bolus feedings.51 Even depleted, stressed patients
used only between 40 and.50 kcal/kg/day, the highest requirement
going to the normally nourished, stressed patient. These patients
have normal metabolic rates which have become somewhat catabolic.
10 50 A careful calculation of calorie requirement can be made
using a formula provided by Horowitz.31 Protein needs perioperatively
will run from 250 mg nitrogen/kg/day for depleted, unstressed
patients to 400 mg nitrogen/ kg/day for stressed patients.10 A
70kg man who has had uncomplicated surgery may need 70 g/day of
protein and a 55 kg woman, 57 g protein.31
Moss (1984) describes eighteen post. cholecystectomy patients
who were given full enteral nutrition with amino acids immediately
postoperatively. Ten of these were given an elemental diet providing
132 g amino acids/day, eight received 66 g amino acids/day, and
controls were fed with a standard hypocaloric solution. In the
unfed controls, decreased branched chain amino acids (BCAAs) were
observed; these increased after three or four days and normal
levels were finally restored after five to ten days. Patients
receiving the higher amount of protein maintained their basal
levels immediately postoperatively, then had increased levels.
Intermediate amino acid feedings (66 g) had lower BCAAs for twenty-four
hours then rapidly returned to normal. Moss correlates this positive
protein balance and increased serum amino acid levels with enhanced
wound healing, resistance to sepsis, and shortened hospital duration.52
Other studies have confirmed the positive nitrogen balance and
reduced hospital duration, but failed to show any decrease in
postoperative complications." 55
Parenteral Nutrition
Direct delivery of calories and nutrients to the bloodstream was
first done in 1656 by Sir Christopher Wren who infused ale and
wine into the veins of dogs. Various improvements over the next
300 years ensued, but it wasn't until 1967 when Dudrick and associates
first developed the use of central serious lines that long-term
survival on parenteral fluids was feasible.56,57 Now, 5400 mOsm
of nutritionally complete, fat-free solution can be provided,
supply 3600 kcal/day and far outdistancing the previous limits
of 1800 mOsm and 1000 kcal possible by the peripheral venous route,
Total parental nutrition (TPN) is indicated in patients who cannot
absorb through the gastrointestinal tract, have severe diarrhea,
disease of small bowel, major surgery, enterocutameous fistulas
and extremely catabolic states, to name a few indications."
Minor surgery patients are generally considered to need less aggressive
nutritional support (e.g. no parenteral nutrition unless severely
malnourished). Within seven days of surgery they should be ingesting
a maintenance diet orally. 31 Elective colectomy patients, however,
were studied for postoperative eating patterns and were shown
to have an average 1,155 kcal of calorie deficit daily in the
first fourteen days post surgery.59 Patients with major surgery
or injury usually need two to three times the RDA postoperatively
to avoid significant weight loss. This is a fascinating example
of stress producing a need for mega-nutrition. If patients have
protein-calorie malnutrition, they need aggressive preoperative
therapy as well.31
Glucose and lipid, though both partially protein sparing, are
insufficient to maintain a positive nitrogen balance in the absence
of exogenous amino acids.60 However, use of dextrose-free amino
acid IV solution has shown no clear benefit.43 A full range of
nutrients including carbohydrates, lipids and protein has been
shown to be more effective.61
A fairly standard IV feeding formula today may consist of two
solutions, one of amino acids, dextrose, electrolytes, vitamins,
and trace elements, and another, lipid emulsion, are used in total
parenteral nutrition (TPN); they are infused simultaneously, The
standard first solution contains 25% dextrose and 5% amino acids
in equal volumes.23 115-120 mmol sodium, 80- 100 mmol potassium,
10 mmol calcium, 12-15 mmol magnesium, and 12-20 mmol phosphorus
are routinely added. Vitamins and trace elements are introduced
as required. In the average adult, 1.5.2 L/day of IV solution
are given. 1.0 to 1.5 liters of lipid are infused concurrently.
These two solutions provide 100 grams of amino acids, 1250-1700
kcal glucose and 1100. 1650 kcal lipid for a total of 2350-3350
kcal/day.42 63
There are many commercially available formulas allowing for accommodation
of requirements imposed by specific diseases, and having the advantages
of "known composition, controlled osmolality and consistency,
ease in preparation and storage, and cost." One must know when
to add vitamin and mineral or amino acid packages which are also
prepackaged.32,64 It is becoming more widely recognized that
steroids, sedatives, antibiotics and anticonvulsants create an
additional need for vitamins.10
The fat portion of an IV feeding has often been administered separately,
however, at least one study shows excellent results with a mixture
of 20% fat emulsion, 8% amino acids, dextrose, electrolytes, vitamins,
and trace minerals.63 It was used from two to thirty-five days
with no adverse results.70 The lipid portion can be useful in
insulin resistent patients, decreasing fatty infiltration of the
liver, and because it does not increase osmolality of the solution
and may decrease (pulmonary diffusion).12 20% and even 30% in
the TV solution are not uncommon.50,65
Complications of intravenous hyperalimentation (IVH) are not uncommon
and include mechanical (pneumo-,hemo-,and hydrothorax, arterial
or nerve injury, embolism), septic (contaminants in solution or
line, sepsis, especially with Staph aureus and candida, septic
embolism and thromboembophlebitis), metabolic (hyper- and hypoglycemia,
hyperammonemia, in. creased lipids, and deficiencies of essential
fatty acids electrolytes, minerals, trace elements, and vitamins).
Continuous TPN is associated with less diarrhea than with intermittent.
Bolus feedings are discouraged.34 Only some of the more important
deficiency states will be discussed.
Potential Nutrient Deficiencies.
Deficiencies Of Certain nutrients have occurred over the years
in association with perioperative nutrition. A review of them
reveals interesting information about deficiency states.
Esssential Fatty Acids
One of the first deficiencies to be discovered was the essential
fatty acids (EFA). In 1972, Caldwell et al described infants an
TPN for five or more months; they noted dermatitis, alopecia,
thrombocytopenia, and impaired wound healing, all of which improved
upon addition of a linoleic acid solution.66 Other regimens have
resulted in increased liver function enzymes, fatty liver and
inclusion bodies in hepatocytes, as early as 6.8 weeks after institution
of TPN.12 In addition, Freund has found that an increase in intraocular
pressure is a useful early sign in detecting EFA deficiency.67
This may have relevance to glaucoma. The authors have seen several
patients obtain lower intraocular pressures with high dose polyunsaturates.
The optimal amount of linoleic acid is believed to be that which
keeps the enoic:tetratenoic ratio less than 0.4; in adults being
repleted, this is approximately 4% of total calorie intake.68
A deficiency state for linolenic acid has likewise been described
by Holman et al who noted neurological symptoms including paresthesia,
numbness, inability to walk, leg pain, and blurring of vision.
Others have challenged this report.
Phosphate
As with several other nutrients, a deficiency syndrome for phosphate
was not discovered unto the 1970's; until this time, TPN solutions
had routinely included the anion. With the advent of "new and
improved" crystalline amino acid solutions lacking phosphate,
however, an acute syndrome of hypophosphatemia was seen to develop
within days of starting on TPN.Lichtman et al,70 Silvis and Paragus,71
and Travis et al,72 all reported acute, marked hypophosphatemia
(< 1.0 mg/dl) in patients on intravenous hyperalimentation; they
noted decreased 2,3-DPG and ATP (both of which require the anion
for phosphorylation) with increased hemoglobin affinity for oxygen
and resultant respiratory difficulty. The full syndrome includes
paresthesia, muscle weakness, encephalopathy, coma, and death.32
Deficiency of phosphate is also associated with impaired glycolysis,
impaired phagocyte function, hemolysis, rhabdomyolysis, and congestive
cardiomyopathy.73 Since phosphate-free IV solutions have been
given for years without development of this syndrome, it is believed
the problem is an intracellular shift of phosphate caused by the
hypercaloric or anabolic effect of the solution. Phosphate has
a role in intermediary metabolism and in cellular/skeletal structure
as phospholipids and hydroxyapatite. Parenteral solutions should
provide 0.5-1.0 mmol/kg/day in stable patients with. out renal
failure; serum levels are the optimal way to monitor treatment.73
Clinicians should be aware of phosphate deficiency caused by excess
calcium intake.
Zinc
In 1976, Kay et al described four patients who after approximately
two weeks on TPN developed diarrhea, dermatitis, alopecia, and
mental depression concurrent with low serum zinc (< 20 mcg/dl,
down form 80-150 mcg/dl pre-TPN).74 They recovered rapidly after
zinc supplementation. Fawaz also reported four stressed patients
with serum zinc levels between 25-56 mcg/dI; he noted eczematoid
dermatitis in all, and decreased hematocrit and albumin in three
of the four patients.75 Arakawa found decreased alkaline phosphate
levels associated with subnormal zinc.76Zinc is involved in production
of alkaline phosphatase and other enzymes and in protein synthesis.
Poor wound healing, impaired immunological function, ageusia,
alopecia, acrodermatitis, and anosmia are associated with low
levels. There are increased losses of zinc with GI fistulas, diarrhea,
zincuria during amino add infusions, and rapid weight gain.32,67,73
Supplementation with 2.5 to 4 mg/day in TPN: is thought to be
sufficient, with an additional 2 mg in acute catabolic states
and 6-12 mg with diarrhea or other intestinal losses.77 It is
possible that higher doses of zinc may produce other benefits
in surgical patients.
Copper
As with zinc, copper deficiency relater to TPN solutions was not
discovered until the 1970's when the crystal line amino acid mixtures,
now free of several trace elements were first introduced. Karpel
and Peder described an infant on prolonged TPN with markedly low
serum copper and ceruloplasmin. Microcytic hypochromic anemia,
hypoplastic bone marrow, retarded bone age, and metaphyseal bone
lesions that corrected with copper were seen.78 Deficiency is
also associated with neutropenia and bacterial infection, and
normocytic normochromic anemia.32 Copper is a cofactor of ceruloplasmin
and is involved in the synthesis of oxidative metalloenzymes and
elastics. Excreted in bile, these requirements increase with diarrhea,
and decrease with liver diseases which block or reduce biliary
excretion. Replacement with 0.5-1.5 mg/day is standard.66
Chromium
Jeejeebhoy reported a woman in 1977' who presented after three
and a half year on TPN with 10% weight loss and peripheral neuropathy
with slow nerve conduction. Her glucose tolerance test was abnormal
and she had moderate hyperglycemia in the fasting state. Free
fatty acids were elevated and her respiratory quotient (RQ) was
low. Both serum and hair levels of chromium were low; all symptoms
corrected with supplemental chromium.79 Chromium is part of the
glucose tolerance factor; it is involved in the potentiation of
insulin. Standard supplementation is provided in a trace elements
package which includes zinc, copper, chromium (1015 mcg/day) and
manganese (0.15-0.8 Mg/day).25 Chromium's role in sugar metabolism
has been confirmed.
Selenium
Although "white muscle disease" (loss of myocytes and replacement
with connective tissue) has been recognized in New Zealand sheep
raised in selenium-deficient soil, it was not until 1979 that
van Rij reported TPN patients with a clinical myopathy that corrected
on 100 mcg/day of selenomethionine.80 An earlier report by Fleming
et at in 1976 described a fatal cardiomyopathy culminating in
ventricular fibrillation in a twenty-four year old man on TPN
for six years.81 Selenium is involved in glutathione peroxidase
and vitamin E metabolism with a vulnerability to deficiency being
associated with low vitamin E levels.68 Decreased enzyme levels
without clinical manifestations were seen by Baptista; replacement
with 100 mcg/day of selenium (as selenous acid) improved selenium
levels while RBC glutathione peroxidase remained impaired.82 Recommendation
for standard replacement has been for 0.04-0.16 mg/day as a toxicity
syndrome has been described at higher levels. For depleted patients,
200-400 mcg/day is suggested.75
Rare Deficiency Syndromes
Other, more rare deficiency syndromes have been reported: molybdenum,
with headache, visual disturbances, and mental changes; biotin,
with dermatitis, blepharitis, alopecia, and delirium; and carnitine,
with jaundice, muscle weakness, and hypoglycemia.69 These differences
point out the need for a complete balance of nutrients from amino
acids to trace elements.
Conclusion
Wound healing requires a complete nutritional effort. The nutritional
influences on wound healing are approached in humans mostly from
the context of overall surgical outcome. Several studies indicate
needs for specific nutrients. Many studies were cited correlating
poor surgical outcome with poor nutritional status. Determinants
for nutritional status are generally agreed to include anthropometric,
serum proteins, immune status, nutritional measurements and many
other indicators but investigators disagree widely as to which
ones serve as the most reliable predictors of surgical outcome.
Deficiencies of nutrients once manifested during TPN are now more
easily avoided with the addition of more fatty acids, amino acids,
vitamins, minerals and trace elements. In the future we expect
to identify more nutrients, trace metals, peptides, and oils that
need to be added to TPN.
References