Carl C. Pfeiffer, Ph.D., M.D. and Scott LaMola, B.S.
Abstract
The essential trace elements zinc and manganese have been noted
as factors in brain disease since the Twenties. The combined use
of zinc and manganese in schizophrenia is based on: 1) Increased
urinary excretion of copper when both zinc and manganese are given
orally 2) Zinc alone causes a decrease in blood manganese and
3) The double deficiency of zinc and manganese frequently is found
in patients with excess copper. The mauve factor (Kryptopyrrole)
is known to increase the excretion of zinc and vitamin B6 (pyridoxine).
In children insufficient levels of zinc and manganese have been
associated with lowered learning ability, apathy, lethargy and
mental retardation. Hyperactive children may be deficient in zinc,
manganese and vitamin B6 and have an excess of lead and copper.
Alcoholism, schizophrenia, Wilson's disease, and Pick's disease
are brain disorders dynamically related to zinc and manganese
levels. Zinc has been employed with success to treat Wilson's
disease, achrodermatitis enteropathica, and specific types of
schizophrenia. Manganese is important in the building and breakdown
cycles of protein and nucleic acid. For RNA chain initiation,
manganese was found to be a better effector than magnesium. Manganese
stimulates adenylate cyclase activity in brain tissue. Because
cyclic-AMP plays a regulatory role in the action of several brain
neurotransmitters, manganese is important in brain function. Owing
to the fact that zinc is well absorbed from the gut but manganese
is poorly absorbed all diagnostic categories may be harmed by
large prolonged oral doses of zinc without manganese. In oral
doses manganese occasionally elevates blood pressure in patients
over 40 years of age. Zinc alone can lower blood pressure in some
hypertensive patients. Chronic use of hydralazine (a manganese
chelator) in rats produced manganese deficiency which resulted
in convulsions. Low blood and serum manganese levels may play
a role in epilepsy possibly by interfering with membrane stability.
Prolonged use of phenothiazines causes tardive dyskinesia. Phenothiazines
might chelate manganese making it unavailable for some presumed
function as an enzyme activator.
Historical
The first suggestion that a trace element deficiency might be
a factor in mental disease was that of Derrien and Benoit (1929)
who found a high level of urinary Zn in a dying porphyric female
patient showing abnormal psychiatric symptoms. The first use of
a trace element as treatment for schizophrenia was that of Reiter
(1927) who found intravenous Mn to be effective. He found that
23/50 patients improved after the injections. Schrijver (1928)
gave manganese chloride intravenously to 23 patients with good
improvement in three and possible improvement in seven. Helweg
(1928) treated 95 chronic schizophrenics, with negative results.
Tindinge (1929) used either oral or intravenous Mn in 75 patients
and found only one dramatic improvement. Reed (1929) used a control
schizophrenic group (30) and found that 18 percent of the controls
were discharged from the hospital in one year while 37 percent
of the Mn treated schizophrenic patients (30) were discharged.
Reed used 2 to 8 ml of a 0.02 molar Mn solution intravenously
twice weekly over a period of 15 weeks; followed by a 0.3 g of
manganese chloride twice daily by mouth. W.M. English (1929) studied
many schizophrenics but had the best results with Mn in those
who had been psychotic only two weeks to three years. Of 38 such
patients an increase in body weight, physical improvement and
mental improvement occurred in 22 patients. Some of the chronic
patients also improved. R.G. Hoskins (1934) used suspended manganese
dioxide intramuscularly in 30 patients with only two improved,
two worse, and 26 unchanged. Although Hoskins failed to follow
the experimental procedure and design of the successful investigators
his study triumphed and manganese hydrochloride intravenously
was no longer used.
We found in 1968 (Pfeiffer and Iliev) that oral Mn produced a
three fold increase in excretion of Cu in schizophrenic patients
and that the combination of Zn and Mn was even more effective
in promoting urinary Cu excretion. Since many schizophrenics had
a Cu overload we used "ziman" drops (10 percent Zn sulfate with
0.5 percent Mn chloride) to reduce their Cu burden. Six drops
of ziman morning and night provides 10 mg of Zn and 3. mg of Mn
which is about 3/4 of the estimated daily need - namely 15 mg
of Zn and 4 mg of Mn. In 1965 Professor Roger Williams called
our attention to the paper of Kimura and Kumura who found the
brains of schizophrenics at autopsy to have only 50 percent of
the Zn content of control brains. This low level of Zn held constant
for the frontal, occipital and hippocampal portions of the brains
studied. We know that Zn is essential in the hippocampal portion
of the brain where histamine is stored in histaminergic nerve
endings. We, therefore purchased an Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer
and analyzed body tissues and juices. We have seen over 15,000
out-patients and each outpatient has had blood serum and hair
analyzed for both the trace and toxic elements.
In the period 1966 to 1971 we observed lasting clinical benefit
with ziman drops in many patients who had high hair or serum Cu
levels and low serum Zn levels. By 1977 we had perfected the method
for whole blood Mn determination so we now encounter schizophrenics
who initially are high in serum Cu and low in both serum Zn and
whole blood Mn. These biochemical abnormalities revert to normal
as the patient improves mentally and physically. In our opinion
the use of Mn and Zn to reduce the Cu burden of the body and restoration
of Zn in the hippocampus allows for a reduction in the need for
major tranquillizers in the schizophrenic. In some cases this
Cu excess with Zn and Mn deficiency is the only biochemical imbalance.
By 1971 we had objective data showing that mauve positive schizophrenic
patients [Kryptopyrroles in the urine - (Irvine et al., 1969)]
actually excreted almost twice as much Zn as did schizophrenic
patients who were not mauve positive. Kryptopyrrole is an avid
aldehyde reacting agent which we have shown to combine irreversibly
with pyridoxal phosphate. The new molecule then chelates Zn with
the combined product appearing in the urine. The whole syndrome
is stress induced so the susceptible patient when stressed, quickly
becomes vitamin B6 and Zn deficient. Armed with this knowledge
we can effectively treat the pyroluric patient ("malvaria" of
Hoffer and Osmond) and we have written several papers on the signs,
symptoms and treatment of pyroluria (Pfeiffer et al., 1974; Pfeiffer
and Bacchi, 1975). By 1977 our method for whole blood Mn was applied
to all out-patients both new and old. This revealed that many
patients who had been treated with Zn alone had become Mn deficient.
With new patients the diagnostic categories with the lowest Mn
levels were the epileptic, nutritional hypoglycemics, pyrolurics
and schizophrenics. Zinc is easily and rapidly absorbed from the
gut but Mn is poorly absorbed and we don't know at present how
to increase the whole blood Mn other than by the administration
of large doses of Mn gluconate daily over a long period of time.
We have tried all of the presently marketed oral preparations
of Mn. We have not tried parenteral or intravenous Mn as a supplement.
Practical Aspects of Manganese Supplements in Man
The physicians at the Center have now had four years' experience
in the use of Mn supplements. In the 1977-79 period we noted low
blood Mn levels in many of our schizophrenic patients and, therefore,
increased the dose of oral Mn using either 10 mg or 50 mg of Mn
as the gluconate. To our surprise the blood Mn level in many instances
continued to be low or go to a lower level. Most of these patients
were receiving 30 mg of Zn as the gluconate morning and night,
which in retrospect is a large dose since the body needs only
10 to 15 mg/day. Patients with normal eating habits would require
less supplementation since 5 to 8 mg is obtained from a good diet.
When the Zn supplement is reduced to 15 mg a day the blood Mn
level will usually rise with a daily dose of 10 to 20 mg of Mn.
Note that this dose is two to four times the recommended daily
intake.
We are at present studying the factors which may increase the
absorption of Mn from the intestinal tract. When normal subjects
in the fasting state take 150 mg of Mn as the gluconate (or amino
acid chelate) this dose does not cause a significant rise in the
serum Mn level over a period of four hours. The eating of a breakfast
high in manganese content does not significantly elevate the serum
Mn levels. The normal serum level is 1.20 + 0.99 ng/g (ppb).
Ninety percent of the blood Mn (normal level, 14.80 ± 3.9 ng/g
[ppb]) is contained in the erythrocyte which has a life of 120
days. The determination of whole blood Mn is useful in our clinic
since patients are seen every three to six months. Patients with
a blood Mn below 8 ng/g (ppb) slowly develop a macrocytosis as
characterized by a high mean corpuscular volume and elevated con
puscular hemoglobin. These patients have normal serum folate and
vitamin B12 levels and the macrocytosis responds to a dietary
supplement of Mn with the Zn supplement reduced to a maximum of
15 mg per day.
With Zn alone and sometimes with Ziman Fortified AM and PM, the
patient's whole blood Mn will decrease over a treatment period
of 4 to 12 months. These low Mn levels can result in depression,
intolerance to oral Zn, possible increase in auto-immune reactions
and the aforementioned macrocytosis. The finding of a lowered
Mn blood level with prolonged Zn supplementation has occurred
in psychiatric, arthritic, senile and cardiac patients (See Fig.
1) Thus all diagnostic categories can be harmed by large prolonged
doses of Zn without Mn. With this new concept we have treated
problem patients with large oral doses of Mn. In one severely
allergic male, age 45 (See Fig. 2), whom we had treated for 15
years, we suggested 50 mg of Mn as the gluconate morning and night.
He felt somewhat better with this dose, so he cautiously increased
the dose to 100 mg, three times per day. Before starting this
dose his blood Mn was 6 ng/g (ppb). After three months of the
big dose, his blood Mn was 11 ng/g (ppb). One month later the
level was 8.5 ng/g (ppb) and after a year and a half later it
was 10.5 ng/g (ppb). Normal is 10 to 20 ng/g (ppb). Physical examination,
blood pressure, pulse and chem screen showed no abnormalities.
During the period of 300 mg of Mn orally per day he gained 11
needed pounds in body weight and was able to tolerate foods that
normally caused severe depressive reactions. With the higher blood
levels of Mn this patient now can tolerate small doses of Zn which
previously caused severe depression.
Manganese Levels in the Hair of Schizophrenics
Other than the therapeutic trials of Mn in schizophrenics by Reiter
and English in 1929, the first demonstration of a possible deficiency
of Mn was reported in our survey in 1974. We found Mn to be low
in the hair of schizophrenics, and in males (but not in females)
Mn decreased with age. Barlow (1979) found Mn to be significantly
lower in the hair of schizophrenics compared to a control population.
Bowen (1972) found the Mn in hair of Indonesian children to be
normal but protein deficient Indonesian children had a level five
times higher. The hair copper level in these same children was
two times higher. Perhaps the continuous ingestion of tropical
fruits (high in Mn) with a low protein diet might account for
the very high Mn level of the protein deficient Indonesian children.
Ryan et a]. (1978) reported Mn hair levels of both male and female
patients diagnosed as multiple sclerotic (MS) to be one-half that
of a normal population. The hair Zn levels of the MS patients
were not lower than the controls.
Manganese and Tardive Dyskinesia
Excesses of the polyvalent metal ions of manganese, mercury, copper,
cadmium and lead all appear to cause malfunctions of the CNS in
animals and man. Manganese is unusual among these ions since neurological
abnormalities have been associated with both a deficiency and
an excess of Mn. Neuroleptic drugs are known to cause tardive
dyskinesia in which the patient exhibits involuntary, rhythmic
movements of the tongue, lips and facial muscles; sometimes exhibiting
abnormal trunk movements or choreoathetoid movements of the extremities.
This condition is usually reversible but in the long run may become
irreversible in some patients.
In his earlier work with psychiatric patients who developed tardive
dyskinesia on neuroleptic drugs, Kunin (1976) tried antiparkinson
agents and Rauwolfia to no avail. He-then recalled the work of
Borg and Cotzias (1972) who reported that phenothiazines form
free radicals with manganic (trivalent) ions in vitro. Manganese
is found in high concentrations in the extrapyramidal system.
He reasoned that phenothiazines might chelate Mn, thus binding
it electrochemically, and that this might make it unavailable
for some presumed function as an enzyme activator. It seemed plausible
that by providing extra dietary Mn the deficiency would be corrected
and the dyskinesia might thereby improve. Kunin (1976) found in
15 cases of tardive dyskinesia treated with Mn, seven were completely
relieved; three cases were much improved; four were improved and
only one was unimproved. Good results followed Mn doses of at
least 15 mg and up to 60 mg/day. Niacin, at doses of 100 to 500
mg, was of significant benefit in treating dyskinesia in three
of the 15 cases. Mean content of Mn in the hair of a psychiatric
patient population averaged 0.8 ppm. The tardive dyskinesia patients
averaged 0.46 ppm. It is concluded that Mn appears to be of value
in treating many cases of tardive dyskinesia and it may also be
of value in preventing the occurrence of dyskinesias.
Manganese and Blood Pressure
In oral doses Mn has not been found harmful, although in patients
over 40 years of age Mn supplementation has occasionally elevated
blood pressure. The elevated blood pressure returns to normal
when Mn is discontinued and Zn alone is used. Zinc is effective
in lowering the blood pressure of some hypertensive patients which
is reminiscent of some of the early work of Schroeder and his
coworkers. Comens (1960), working in Schroeder's laboratory, found
that chronic hydralazine (a Mn chelater) in rats produced Mn deficiency
which resulted in convulsions. These convulsions were antidoted
by Mn but not by potassium, calcium, cobalt, zinc or nickel injections.
Comens (1956) also postulated that Mn deficiency could be a factor
in lupus erythematosus and other collagen diseases. Two of the
side effects of hydralazine therapy, when used to lower blood
pressure in man, are arthritis and lupus erythematosus. An acute
rheumatic state occurs in as many as 10 percent of the hypertensive
patients treated with hydralazine. From these findings we can
conclude:
1) Zn, by antagonizing Mn, may lower the blood pressure of some
hypertensives.
2) Zn, when used to treat arthritic patients, should be carefully
balanced with adequate Mn to sustain any beneficial effect. 3)
Mn may be important in preventing autoimmune reactions.
Manganese and Seizures
Mn deficiency also affects cerebral motor function. Hurley et
al. (1963) demonstrated a relationship between seizure activity
and Mn deficiency in rats. The seizure threshold was found to
be significantly lower in Mn deficient animals. Tanaka (1977)
has presented a preliminary report on low blood Mn levels in epileptic
patients.
Sohler et al. (1979) compared blood Mn levels in a group of patients
with seizure activity to a control group. Blood Mn levels from
control subjects had a mean of 14.8 ng/g (ppb) while serum levels
were 1.2 ng/g (ppb). The blood Mn levels were significantly lower
in the patients with seizure activity, 9.9 ± 4.9 ng/g (ppb) p
< 0.005). The clinical significance of the low blood Mn levels
remains to be evaluated. In uncontrolled trials we find that Mn
is helpful in controlling seizures of both minor and major types.
Both Mn and choline deficiencies are believed to interfere with
membrane stability and this could be responsible for facilitating
the propagation of seizure activity. We suggest these findings
warrant the use of dietary supplements of Mn for the control of
seizure activity. The remission of seizures is frequently dramatic.
Apparently the essential trace element Mn is a basic, direct legacy
from vegetable life to animal life. Tropical fruits are naturally
high in Mn with tea leaves the highest. Plants cannot convert
the sun's energy without Mn (photosynthesis) and man cannot live
without Mn since at least six important enzymes require Mn for
normal function. Compared to Zn, Mn is poorly absorbed and both
Mn and Zn are rapidly excreted. The absorption of Mn and Cu are
equally slow but Cu is sequestered in the absence of Zn and Mn
and may cause harmful effects. Because of the slow absorption
of Mn the beneficial effects of Mn in man may not be evident for
weeks and months. Except for the occasional elevation of blood
pressure, oral Mn is without serious side effects. The use of
Mn food supplements and foods high in Mn can be tried in some
of the diseases which still baffle the medical profession. Patience
may provide good rewards with Mn.
Manganese and the "Empty" Basophil
The blood histamine level correlates with the absolute basophil
count since most of the blood histamine is contained in the basophils
(Pfeiffer, 1972). On all patients we perform both determinations
and expect the histamine to be near the mean of 48 ng/ml and the
basophil count at about 35 cells per cu milliliter. When the patient
is Mn deficient some patients may have a high basophil count,
i.e. 75, with a normal or low blood histamine. We call this the
"empty" basophil syndrome. The patient responds clinically to
an oral Mn supplement and has a rise in the blood histamine level
to correlate with the high basophil count. The opposite - a high
blood histamine and a low absolute basophil count is usually a
laboratory error - frequently we find that the blood was taken
late on Friday and the basophils were then counted on Monday.
The elapsed time of 48 hours allows disintegration of the basophils.
Summary - Manganese
Although often ignored by nutrition conscious individuals, Mn
is an essential trace metal frequently deficient in our diet.
A component of at least six known enzymes, Mn is required for
efficient sugar metabolism, for the production of cartilage -
a vital structural component of our bodies, and for the manufacture
of cyclic AMP - a cellular second messenger.
We know that Mn deficient animals suffer impaired growth, reproductive
problems, and a shortened life span. With a severe deficiency,
animals cannot stand up because of defective cartilage formation.
Humans with low Mn levels can suffer chronic joint pains, particularly
in the knees and back. "Growing pains" often disappear when our
young patients take adequate Mn with zinc along with their vitamins.
And, since the discs between the vertebrae consist largely of
cartilage, widespread Mn deficiency might be responsible for the
high incidence of back problems in the developed, more carnivorous,
world.
In addition, low Mn levels have been associated with epilepsy
and schizophrenia. Studies dating back to 1929 indicate that
schizophrenics improve with supplementary Mn and our experience
with Mn deficient schizophrenics at the Brain Bio Center supports
this. We have also discovered that Mn deficient patients may suffer
depression which clears up when Mn is included in the treatment
program. Seizure patients may respond dramatically to Mn. Deficiency
may lead to autoimmune diseases.
We find that patients with either hypoglycemia or diabetes need
extra Mn to help normalize blood sugar levels. This isn't surprising
since in Mn deficient animals, the insulin secreting cells of
the pancreas atrophy - and insulin is the body's crucial regulator
of sugar metabolism. Interestingly, low levels of this trace metal
during early development may lead to malformation of the ear's
vestibular system, the ear's mechanism responsible for maintaining
balance. Young children who are slow to walk may require Mn supplements.
Unfortunately, most diets, even the best planned, tend to be deficient
in this important trace metal. Our Mn deficient farmlands often
produce fruits and vegetables lacking adequate levels. And, many
of our frequently eaten foods contain little Mn. For example,
meat, even liver, provides little Mn. Foods rich in Mn include
nuts, whole grains, spices, legumes, and tea leaves. Tropical
fruits such as pineapple, banana, papaya, and mango are particularly
good sources. However, patients with low Mn blood or hair Mn levels
will need supplementary Mn in addition to a good diet. Fortunately,
Mn is well tolerated, even at high doses (up to 300 mg/day). However,
occasionally in patients over forty, Mn can raise blood pressure
and produce tension headaches. If this occurs, the Mn dose should
be stopped until the blood pressure normalizes and the headaches
disappear. Dried or fresh tropical fruits and tea can then be
used as a source of Mn.
Low Zinc and High Copper in Some Schizophrenics
In 1966, when we found that some schizophrenic patients had low
levels of blood histamine, we turned to a study of their Zn and
Cu levels as possible factors in the storage and destruction of
body histamine. Those patients registering low in histamine were
also low in zinc and serum folate and high in serum Cu (Pfeiffer
and Iliev, 1972). Occasionally a high Cu level was accompanied
by a high serum creatine phosphokinase (CPK) level. Meltzer et
al. (1969) have studied serum CPK extensively. In sheep poisoned
with Cu, the CPK levels are tremendously high (Thompson and Todd,
1974), so that a high serum Cu level plus increased motor activity
may cause a rise in CPK in the occasional schizophrenic. Over
a 10 year period we have used folic acid and vitamin B12 to treat
patients with low serum histamine levels and high serum Cu levels.
These two vitamins reduce the need for the large doses of niacin
used in megavitamin therapy; the use of folate and vitamin B12
in histapenic patients makes reasonable doses of niacin effective.
With these nutrients, plus Zn and Mn, the Cu burden of the patient
decreased over a three month period, and the blood histamine level
usually rises to a normal level.
Experience in the diagnosis and treatment of large numbers of
schizophrenic patients has led us to separate three main biotypes:
50 percent are histapenic (low blood histamine, high serum Cu,
low folate), 20 percent are histadelic (high blood histamine,
low or normal serum Cu), and 30 percent are normal in Cu and histamine
but excrete large quantities of kryptopyrrole in their urine,
depleting them of vitamin B6 and Zn (Pfeiffer, 1975). We have
continued to characterize schizophrenia around the histamine axis,
accumulating empirical, experimental, and theoretical support
for these biotypes. Many biochemical abnormalities have been reported
in schizophrenia; rather than being contradictory, much of the
previous research supports our classification.
The low-histamine (histapenic) biotype of schizophrenia is frequently
an environmentally produced copper overload with a resultant nutrient
imbalance. Patients may be deficient in folic acid, vitamin B12,
niacin, Zn and Mn. The biochemical imbalance is characterized
by oxidation of amines, low serum folate (Pfeiffer and Braverman,
1979), slowed metabolism (Carmel, 1978), fat accumulation, and
decreased mean energy content of the quantitative EEG (Dow, 1971;
Goldstein and Sugerman, 1969). Behavioral symptoms in high-copper
histapenia include paranoia and hallucinations in younger patients,
but depression may predominate in older patients. The patient
is usually classified as having chronic or process schizophrenia.
Others have found that the administration of folic acid will correct
severe psychosis caused by folate deficiency. A 15-year-old girl
was found to suffer homocysteinuria and symptoms of "schizophrenia".
She was shown to have impaired N5,10-tetrahydrofolate reductase
activity. Enzyme inactivity caused diminished production of N5methyltetrahydrofolate.
Methylation of homocysteine was thus impaired, resulting in homocysteinuria.
Folate and pyridoxine greatly improved the patient's condition
(Barber and Spaeth, 1969). There have been many well-documented
reports of other folate -responsive behavioral disorders (Botez
et al. 1977; Botez and Lambert, 1977; Botez et al. 1977; Carney,
1975).
Folic Acid in Low-Histamine High Copper Patients
We have used folic acid plus vitamin B12 for over 12 years to
treat histapenic high copper patients who have hallucinations
or paranoia in the early years of life or depression in later
years. This is effective therapy that augments the effects of
zinc, niacin, and vitamin C. With this therapy the serum Cu level
is reduced, and the blood histamine rises to the normal range
of 40 to 70 ng/ml after five to six months of therapy. The psychiatric
symptoms decrease as the biochemical values approach more nearly
normal levels (Pfeiffer and Braverman, 1979).
Folic Acid in High-Blood Histamine Normal-Copper Patients
Histadelic (high-blood histamine) patients are characterized by
fast oxidation, little fat, long fingers and toes, severe depression,
compulsions, and phobias. These patients respond to mild antifolate
drugs such as phenytoin and agents that decrease histamine such
as calcium salts and methionine in doses one to two g/day. Folic
acid makes histadelic patients worse, and even the folic acid
in food may cause seasonal depression, which we have termed "salad
bowl depression." A reducing diet composed mainly of New Zealand
spinach or lettuce has caused depression in some histadelic patients.
These examples are obviously dietary extremes, but the patient
who is depressed each summer in the salad season may be histadelic.
Even the 0.4-mg (400-µg) dose of folic acid in many multivitamins
is enough to produce increased depression in the histadelic patient.
When a mildly depressed histadelic patient is given one mg of
folic acid per day, a severe agitated depression may result. Therefore,
we do not use folic acid in any schizophrenic patient until we
know the absolute basophil count or the blood histamine level.
Since the blood histamine is contained primarily in the basophils,
the absolute basophil count may frequently serve to differentiate
histapenic and histadelic patients. Therapy with niacin, folic
acid, and zinc-manganese can change a low-blood histamine (histapenic)
patient into a high-blood histamine depressed patient (Foreman
and Mangor, 1973). This has occurred many times in our experience
and is corrected by a reduction in the dose of folic acid or elimination
of folic acid for a week and thereafter the use of a smaller dosage.
Our usual one to two mg/day dose of folic acid is sufficient for
the histapenic high copper patient.
Some of the florid symptoms in the high copper histapenic patient
will respond promptly to therapy with folic acid, niacin, vitamin
C, zinc, and manganese. The drippy palm syndrome which forces
the patient to carry a wad of tissues in each hand to absorb the
sweat, responds within one to four weeks to this vitamin-mineral
regime. The hypomania, hallucinations, and mind racing are subdued
within three to four weeks. In other patients insomnia may be
rectified in the same period. The degree of paranoia decreased
very slowly, so that full remission may take 12 to 15 months.
Relief of paranoia parallels the attainment of a normal Cu level
in the blood serum.
The simple histapenia-histadelia concept allows a therapeutic
trial of "running for the other goal line." If a patient worsens
with folic acid and niacin, this therapy is stopped. Then the
history and laboratory data are reviewed, and the patient may
be tried on methionine, calcium, and phenytoin therapy
to see if this provides improvement. Many allergic patients do
not store histamine in their basophils because of antigen-antibody
interaction. Thus, our allergic patient may have an abnormally
low blood histamine.
Excess copper is the primary imbalance of histapenics. The Cu
comes from the drinking water, food, and "vitamins plus minerals,"
which are overloaded with two mg of copper. Diphenylhydantoin
(DPH) elevated copper levels (Vasiliades and Sahawneh, 1975).
High Cu levels antagonize folic acid through a complex web of
trace metal interactions. Pregnant women and young women on the
birth control pill will have abnormally low blood histamine levels
because of the high estrogen levels. Copper levels also rise with
the increase in estrogens. High copper levels increase the activity
of histaminase (diaminoxidase), which is a copper-containing enzyme
(Jensen and Olesen, 1969; Jonassen, 1976; Torok, 1970). Vitamin
C-deficient guinea pigs show progressive rises in serum copper
levels.
Pellagrins have elevated serum, hair, and urinary copper levels;
skin histidine is low (Rifkind and Heim, 1977; Vasantha, 1970).
These return to normal with niacin treatment. Reduced availability
of NADH has been reported in folate deficiency. The skin of pantothenic
acid-deficient rats has a fivefold increase in copper level, as
compared with controls. It has been reported that a single large
dose of pantothenic acid effectively lowers the high serum Cu
level for a one week period. Plasma concentrations of Zn decrease
during pregnancy, whereas Cu levels increase. Zinc and Cu are
antagonistic in the human body and probably compete for the same
sites on the protein carrier, metallothionine. Histamine is stored
in the mast cells and basophils in a zinc-heparin-histamine complex
(Kazimierczar and Maslinski, 1974; Keller and Sorkin, 1970).
Zinc and Neural Function
Zinc appears to play a role in axonal transport and neuronal microtubule
and tubulin synthesis and assembly (Amos and Baker, 1979; Baker
and Amos, 1978; Larsson et al., 1977; Tamm et al., 1979). Axoplasmic
flow and axonal and dendritic transport are responsible for delivery
of various macromolecules to distant parts of the neuron. Axonal
transport occurs for opiate receptors in rat vagus nerve, and
muscarinic cholinergic receptors in vagus sciatic and splenic
nerves. Axonal flow may be common to all receptors (Young et al.,
1980). Zinc ions induce tubulin to form transport sheets as well
as increase the number of neurofilaments. Toxic concentrations
of Zn can produce abnormal tubulin aggregates (Gaskin et al.,
1978). In segments of rat peripheral nerves immersed in zinc chloride
solutions buffered with Zn ions neurotubules are stabilized. Zinc
also has an essential role in brain tubulin phosphorylation (Larsson
et al., 1977).
Small amounts of zinc 5 X 10-6M stimulate rapid axonal transport
of proteins in an in vitro system using frog ganglia and nerve
(Edstrom and Mattsson, 1975). Zinc probably stimulates axonal
transport by stabilizing rat brain microtubules and ribosomes
(Edstrorn and Mattsson, 1975). Zinc, at concentration of 5 X 10-6
increased synthesis to 140 percent of the control and protein
transport to 175 percent of the control value. In certain concentrations,
Zn appears to be important for both protein synthesis and axoplasmic
flow. Metal chelation of Zn causes nerve degeneration, while Zn
toxicity causes fast axonal transport resulting in a distal concentration
of membrane protein which may proceed to defective maintenance
of axon terminal structures and loss of function.
Zinc is also the most important trace metal in subcellular DNA
and RNA fractions. Both DNA and RNA polymerases are Zn metalloenzymes.
Zinc's primary importance in nucleic acid metabolism may explain
much of its role in neuron maturation and proliferation.
Brain Development and Zinc
Zinc is an essential nutrient in the development of neurons of
the normal brain. Rats Zn deficient in prenatal and early postnatal
periods (gestational-lactational) develop abnormal brains. In
adults rendered Zn deficient only postnatally, abnormal behavior
is manifest without demonstrable abnormal structure. Both hippocampal
and cerebellar development in rats occur postnatally with the
cerebellar cortex acquiring nearly all its
cellular constituents and the hippocampus acquiring 85 percent
of its neurons during the first three weeks of life (Hurley and
Shrader, 1972). Zinc is involved in the maturation and function
of the mossy fibre pathway. Histochemical observations indicated
increasing levels of Zn in the hippocampal mossy fibre layer after
20 days of age. Between 18 and 22 days hippocampal Zn increased
by 35 percent to reach adult levels. Axoplasmic transport of Zn
occurs from granule cell perikarya to their terminal boutons (Crawford
and Connor, 1972). Zinc deficiency during the critical period
for brain growth permanently affects brain function. When this
deficiency is imposed throughout the latter third of pregnancy,
brain size is decreased, there is a reduced total brain cell count
and the cytoplasmic nuclear ratio is increased, implying an impairment
of cell division in the brain during the critical period of macroneuronal
proliferation (Hurley and Shrader, 1972). In adult life, male
rats so treated display impaired shock avoidance and female rats
are significantly more aggressive at a high level of shock than
adult females whose dams were Zn sufficient during pregnancy (Halas
and Sandstead, 1975; Underwood, 1971). Zinc deficient animals
are more susceptible to a standard stress.
Zinc deficiency has been shown to impair DNA, RNA and protein
synthesis in the brains of suckling rats (Fosmire et at., 1975).
Zinc deficiency results in impaired incorporation of thymidine
into brain DNA. Incorporation of sulfur into protein is also decreased.
Zinc deficiency also decreases the concentration of total lipid
in brain while phospholipids and fatty acids are not affected.
Rat pups suckled for 21 days by dams fed a zinc deficient diet
demonstrated impaired body growth and smaller cerebella and hemispheres
compared to pups given adequate zinc (Fosmire et al., 1975). A
smaller hippocampus and a marked retention of the external grandular
layer of the cerebellum are associated with zinc deficiency (Buell
et al., 1977). A deficiency of dietary Zn during the suckling
period of the rat results in the pups having smaller forebrains,
reduced cell numbers, and decreased RNA and DNA (Fosmire et al.,
1975). Zinc deficiency in pregnant rats affects pups' liver greater
than brain. Livers contain only one-third of the normal amount
of Zn. Total brain Zn was spared by comparison. Buell et al. (1977)
found that postnatal Zn deficiency in rats results in fewer brain
neurons with a decrease in the total amount of DNA. The hippocampus
showed similar deficits.
Zinc and Hormones
Zinc deficiency affects hypothalamic pituitary thyroid function.
Thyrotropin releasing hormone content was decreased in the zinc
deficient rat (Morley et al., 1980). Ultimately triiodothyronine
(T3) and thyroxin levels were decreased. The hypothalamic axis
susceptibility to Zn deficiency may explain the dynamic relationship
between testosterone and Zn. Injections of testosterone or dihydrotestosterone
in mice restores normal zinc content (Donovan and Thomas, 1980)
while Zn deficiency decreases serum production and delays puberty
(Prasad, 1966).
Elevations in hypothalamic Zn concentrations in the rat appear
to correlate with the release of gonadotropin releasing hormone
and gonadotropins which occurs between proestrus and estrus and
after castration, although this, of course, does not establish
a causal relation (Merriam et al., 1979). Hypothalamic Zn ions
rise with gonadotropin secretions (Merriam et al., 1979; Root
et al., 1979). Hypogonadism occurs with Zn deficiency (Caggiano
et al., 1969; Prasad, 1966).
Zinc deficiency inhibits essential fatty acid metabolism to prostaglandins
(PG) either by blocking linoleic acid desaturation to gamma -
linoleic acid or by inhibiting mobilization of dihomo - gamma
linolenic acid from tissue membrane stores (Cunnane and Horrobin,
1980). Prolactin and Zn have similar actions on PGE1 formation
and prolactin enhances flow of fluid from fetal to maternal compartments
(Manku et al., 1975; Manku et al., 1979). Zinc deficiency can
result in polyhydraminos (Manku et al., 1979). Opiates may have
an effect on PGE1 synthesis which is opposite to that of Zn and
there is evidence that reduced PGE1 production (possibly due to
an endogenous opioid) may play a role in schizophrenia (Horrobin
et al., 1978; Horrobin and Morgan, 1980). An enkephalin degrading
amino peptidase from rat brain homogenates is a Zn metalloenzyme(Schnebli
et al., 1979). A higher than normal proportion of arachidonate
was found in the fatty acids of Zn deficient skin (Bettger et
al., 1980). PGE2 and PGF2 have opposing effects on Zn transport
and may act as regulators of the intestinal mucosa transport of
Zn (Song and Adham, 1979).
Zinc deficiency and thyroid hormone shortage occurring in both
cretinism and myxedema have similar signs, ie. retarded growth,
reduced appetite and activity, impaired development of skin and
hair (Hartoma et al., 1979). Zinc deficiency symptoms may be mediated
by excess glucocorticoids since Zn depletion results in elevation
of glucocorticoids. Elevated glucocorticoids and Zn deficiency
both result in death of thymic lymphocytes (Donovan and Thomas,
1980). A deficiency of nerve growth factor may occur with Zn deficiency.
One nerve growth factor is a small basic protein with three distinct
types of sub-units (Vinores and Guroff, 1980). Two molecules of
Zn are present in the complex and Zn participates in holding the
structure together (Dunn et al., 1980; Pattison and Dunn, 1975).
In the absence of Zn the subunits separate. Nerve growth factor
is required for the survival and development of certain sympathetic
and sensory neurons. It is equally clear that nerve growth factor
affects a wide variety of other cells as well. Nerve growth factors
are present on the plasma membrane and almost certainly at the
synaptic ending as well (Dunn et al., 1980). Nerve growth factor
action increased dendritic attachments which requires elevated
levels of RNA synthesis, which is Zn dependant.
Zinc and Amino Acids
Zinc deficiency greatly alters amino acid metabolism and balance.
Some amino acids have important neurotransmitter functions in
the brain. Hsu (1977) studied the effects of Zn deprivation on
the levels of free amino acid in plasma, urine, and skin extracts
of rats. He found significantly higher concentrations of threonine,
leucine, and isoleucine both in the urine and plasma of Zn - deficient
animals. Higher concentrations of taurine, glutamic acid, valine,
and lysine as well as urea were also observed in the Zn deficient
urine. A Zn deficient diet causes anorexia and cyclic feeding
behavior in rats. Zinc deficiency causes a significant increase
in the brain catecholamines; norepinephrine and dopamine (Wallwork
and Sandstead, 1981). Total plasma amino acids are increased (Wallwork
et al., 1981). Histidine was especially elevated while plasma
glutamic acid was depressed. Histamine from histidine, glutamic
acid directly, acetylcholine from choline, serotonin from tryptophan
and catecholamines from tyrosine are neurotransmitters affected
by dietary control. Changes in amino acid levels in Zn deficiency
were affected by abnormalities in amino acid utilization and excretion
(Wallwork et al., 1981). Unfortunately, amino acid distribution
in the brain of Zn deficient animals has not been studied, although
the brain is not as sensitive as some of the tissues described.
For example, Zn concentration in the brain is unaffected by marasmus
or kwashiorkor (Lehmann et al., 1971).
Zinc and Behavior
Zinc deficiency in humans is associated with apathy, lethargy,
amnesia, and mental retardation, often with considerable irritability,
depression and paranoia (Prasad et al 1978). Caldwell et al. (1973)
have shown that the rats born to mildly Zn deficient mothers are
mentally retarded and do not learn as well as rats from Zn supplemented
mothers. Prior to the above studies Caldwell and co-workers observed
a significantly inferior learning ability, as measured by water
maze and platform avoidance conditioning tests, in the surviving
offspring of mildly Zn-deficient mothers, compared to similar
rats from Zn-supplemented mothers. These effects of Zn deficiency
were subsequently confirmed and extended (Halas and Sandstead,
1975; Sandstead et al., 1972; Sandstead et al., 1977; Underwood,
1971). Colleagues visiting Iran and Egypt are told that 30 percent
of the young children are slow learners. It may not be a coincidence
that these areas of the world which have been farmed for centuries
no longer have much available Zn in the soil (Prasad, 1966). Hesse
et al. (1979) have found that adult rats chronically deprived
of dietary Zn do not behave as hippocampal intact animals; the
evidence suggests that the deficiency alters the electrophysiological
properties of normally Zn rich hippocampal mossy fibers (Hesse,
1979). The behavioral characteristics of these animals differed
from controls and were substantially parallel to those reported
for animals with excess glucocorticoids, i.e., impaired passive
avoidance, open field activity and maze alternation (Hesse et
a]., 1979). Zinc deficient rats show latency in the platform box
test, cul de sac and retrace errors, and open field errors (Caldwell
et a]-, 1973; Sandstead et a]., 1972; Sandstead et al., 1977).
Zinc deficient rats (Bradford et al., 1981) show significant differences
in stereotypic behavior (grooming licking) and motor function
(rapid changes in position, backward locomotion and rapid jerky
movements). These behavioral abnormalities correlated with high
levels of striatal catecholamines.
Zinc ions can mimic ouabain when injected intraventricularly and
can produce epileptic seizures in rats. Serum zinc levels in treated
epileptics are significantly decreased as compared to age and
sex matched controls (Barbeau and Donaldson, 1974). In contrast,
elevated Zn levels (possible B6 deficiency?) in serum have been
found in baboons moderately sensitive to photically induced seizures
(Alley et al., 1981). The hippocampus is implicated in epileptic
seizures (Silfvenius et al., 1980). Zn may also have an important
role in transmitter release on the basis of the inhibitory effect
on Na-K ATPase (Barbeau and Donaldson, 1974). Seizures which occur
after burns of the skin are possibly due to Zn or Mn deficiency
caused by excess demands of tissue regeneration (Hughes and Cayaffa,
1973). Zinc and Mn are important for normal otolith formation
and, therefore, necessary for normal balance. Disperception can
occur during deficiency states and Zn has been useful in otology
(Ruggles and Linquist, 1976). Henkin et al. (1975) have noted
that one of syndromes of acute Zn loss is cerebellar dysfunction.
Zinc supplementation following Zn deficiency reverses excessive
emotionality (Pfeiffer, 1975). Each of three major phenothiazines
increases the total brain zinc uptake in all animals tested, more
in rats than in mice (Czerniak and. Haim, 1971). The following
regional changes were detected in rat brains. Occipitotemporal
cortex, thalamus and hippocampus became more zincophilic, the
thalamus especially under chloropromazine and the hippocampus
under perphenazine treatment. Zinc deficiency clearly alters behavior
through both primary and secondary metabolic pathways.
Brain Content of Zinc and Disease
McLardy (1973) observed a 30 percent deficit of Zn brain content
in early onset schizophrenics and chronic alcoholics. Other researchers
have observed a decrease in hippocampal Zn in schizophrenics (Kimura
and Kumura, 1965). Zinc deficiency elevates catecholamines in
rat brain (Bradford et al., 1981; Wallwork and Sandstead, 1981)
and zinc deficiency with dopamine excess might be a frequent biological
dyad in schizophrenia. Lead displaces Zn from the hippocampal
mossy fiber system (Bushwell and Bowman 1979; Niklowitz and
Yeager, 1973). Rabbits exposed to lead-poisoned water have uniformly
elevated frontal cortex, cerebellar, and hippocampal lead. Copper,
iron, and Zn are significantly decreased in these regions. The
decrease in Zn was most significant in the interior hippocampus.Staton
et al. (1976) have also described Zn deficiency-Cu excess presenting
as schizophrenia- In the Wilson's disease patient only Zn uptake
is increased since Cu is already overloaded (Aaseth et al-, 1979).
It is clear that brain Zn content changes during disease states
and that brain Zn deficiency is possibly dynamically related to
schizophrenia, alcoholism, Wilson's disease and lead poisoning.
Excess Zinc
Zinc excess appears to have almost no brain toxicity, although
patients show some significant somatic effects (Pfeiffer et al.,
1980; Snyder, 1979). Zinc has very little toxicity measured by
morphological and histochemical changes occurring in the brain
of rats fed 100 mg of zinc oxide (via gastric tube) Kozik, 1979;
Kozik et al., 1980). The rats developed minor degenerative changes
of neurocytes (vascularization) along with moderate proliferation
of the oligodendroglia and of undifferentiated subependymal glial
cells. Cerebral activities of acid phosphatase (elevated in prostatic
cancer), ATPase and acetylcholinesterase were found, while increased
activity of thiamine pyrophosphatase was observed. The activity
of carbonic anhydrase, a Zn enzyme, normally increases with age
but was lower than normal in white matter from Krabbe disease
and adrenoleukodystrophy (Lees et al., 1980).
Pick's disease is a degenerative dementia with onset in the 5th
to 7th decades, characterized by apragniatism, stereotyped gestures,
bizarre behavior, decreased speech leading to complete mutism,
prefrontal signs and in some cases, pyramidal and extrapyramidal
signs. Morphologically, its most characteristic form consists
of atrophy of the temporal and frontal lobes, with gliosis and
demyelination. In addition, two types of pathological changes
in the neuronal bodies are observed: argyrophilic inclusions and
neuronal ballooning. The lesions in Pick's disease are observed
initially in the hippocampus, and subsequently extend to the temporal,
insular and orbitofrontal cortex, and sometimes even to the parietal
cortex. The hypothesis of an excess of Zn in patients with Pick's
disease is supported by postmortem hippocampal Zn measurements
(Constantinidis et al., 1977; Constantinidis and Tissot, 1980).
Hippocampal Zn is higher in Pick's disease than in Alzheimer's
disease or controls. Similarly, the blood cells and urine of patients
with Pick's disease contain more Zn than those of patients with
Alzheimer's disease or controls. Zinc chelators (Disulfiram, calcium
EDTA) increase urinary excretion of Zn. This increase is greater
in patients with Pick's disease than in patients with Alzheimer's
disease (Constantinidis and Tissot, 1980).
Zinc and Schizophrenias
The schizophrenias are biochemically numerous, so the simplistic
term "schizophrenia" should be avoided. At least seven different
biochemical imbalances can produce clinical symptoms which are
indistinguishable by the so-called research diagnostic criteria
for simplistic schizophrenia. As an example, Wilson's disease,
a Cu overload disorder, can be marked by psychosis and hallucinations.
Oral zinc has an antagonistic effect on the reabsorption of Cu
in the gastrointestinal tract and, for that reason, is considered
valuable in the treatment of this disease (Hoogenraad et al.,
1978). We have already mentioned the work of Derrien and Benoit
(1929), and Kimura and Kumura (1969) who suggested or found Zn
to be involved in mental disease. In 1967 Pfeiffer and Iliev reported
low blood histamine levels in schizophrenic patients histamine
is stored with zinc. A definite percentage of psychiatric patients
have been found to have the chemical kryptopyrrole in their urine.
Kryptopyrrole reacts avidly with all aldehyde chemicals, including
pyridoxal (Pfeiffer et al., 1974). The resulting kryptopyrrole-pyridoxal
complex by chelating Zn produces a Zn deficiency as well as a
severe pyridoxine deficiency. These patients, whom we have termed
pyroluric, respond for the most part to vitamin B6 and Zn therapy
(Pfeiffer and Bacchi, 1975; Pfeiffer, 1976). Pyroluria is a form
of schizophrenic porphyria, similar to acute intermittent porphyria
where both pyrroles and porphyrins are excreted in the urine in
excess (Braverman, 1978). Both Zn, ALA dehydratase, vitamin B6,
and ALA synthetase, are important co-factors in the pyrrole porphyria-heme
pathway.
Evans (1980) found that rats absorb one and one-half times as
much dietary Zn if given vitamin B6. Specifically 71 percent of
dietary Zn was absorbed when the animals were given 40 mg of the
vitamin per kilogram of diet- Only 46 percent of the Zn was absorbed
when two mg of vitamin B6 per kilogram were given (Evans and Johnson,
1980). This effect may be due to vitamin B6s role in the tryptophanpicolinic
acid pathways.
Practical Aspects of Zinc Supplements in Man
The physicians at the Princeton Brain Bio Center (PBBC) have had
15 years of experience in the use of trace element dietary supplements
since Zn therapy was started in 1967. In 1968 we found in man
that Zn plus Mn was more effective than Zn alone in eliminating
Cu via the urinary pathway. Approximately one half of the patients
coming to the PBBC have a Cu overload as shown by blood serum
or hair analysis. Molybdenum and occasionally d-penicillamine
are used with Zn and Mn to control Cu overload- The Zn recommendations
are based on our experience in 70,000 clinic visits of over 15,000
patients wherein the blood, Zn, Cu, Fe and Mn were determined
at each visit. In many patients blood aluminum, molybdenum, lead
and rubidium were also determined. Oral Zn salts are readily and
equally well absorbed (Sohler and Pfeiffer, 1980). So called "chelates"
(Zn added to amino acid digests) have no advantage and are more
costly. The surgeons, pioneering in the use of adequate Zn for
wound healing, introduced the So mg Zn (as the sulfate) tablet.
The actual weight of Zn as the sulfate (ZnSO4.7H20) is Z20 mg.
The body needs only 15 mg of elemental Zn per day so this original
50 mg tablet is too large and may produce nausea and diarrhea.
The use of Zn, 15 mg (as the gluconate) should be standard. This
lower dose seldom produces nausea if taken with food. For children,
infants and senile patients a liquid preparation of Zn plus vitamin
B6 and ziman (Zn plus Mn) with vitamin B6 are available from either
Willner Chemists, New York City or Bronson Laboratories, LaCanada,
CA.
Immediate side effects of dietary Zn supplement may be occasional
nausea, more than normal sweating, intolerance to alcohol and
transient worsening of depression of hallucinations. All of these
reactions respond to lessening of the dose or taking the 15 mg
of Zn with food. The immediate effect of Zn may be a decrease
in serum iron level. With 15 mg of Zn this is rare and is usually
self-corrective so that iron supplements are not needed, (No iron
therapy unless serum iron level drops below 50 mcg percent!).
Continued massive doses of Zn, up to 5000 mg per day decreased
both serum Cu levels and ceruloplasmin levels in one female patient
(Pfeiffer et al., 1980). This was corrected by the daily use of
Theragran-M which contains 2 mg of Cu. Patients on Zn supplements
may have more persistent visual after-images and the time for
dark adaptation of the eyes may be prolonged.
The most insidious effect of excess Zn over a period of years
is the reduction of blood Mn, 90 percent of which is contained
in the erythrocytes. This produces macrocytosis (increased mean
cell volume [MCV] and mean cell hemoglobin [MCH]) when the blood
Mn level falls to less than 8 ppb (normal 15 ppb). Low blood Mn
levels may accentuate depression, allergies, and seizure activity
in epileptics. Manganese is poorly absorbed from the intestine
and, while only 5 mg is needed per day, the patient may need as
much as 300 mg of Mn as the gluconate to attain the normal blood
level of 15 ppb. Zinc dietary supplements increase grand mal seizures
in epileptics so Mn supplements should be started initially and
Zn cautiously added one month later when the blood levels of Zn,
Mn, and Cu are known.
The reduction in Mn may be beneficial in older patients in that
long term oral Zn will lower blood pressure probably as a result
of lowered Mn levels. One antihypertensive drug, hydralazine,
is a Mn chelating agent which lowers blood pressure and blood
Mn levels. Manganese orally in susceptible older patients may
produce hypertensive headaches which subside when the Mn is discontinued.
One of the side effects of hydralazine therapy is lupus erythematosis,
an autoimmune disease. Thus, prolonged large doses of Zn may,
by lowering Mn levels, increase the patient's susceptibility to
autoimmune reactions.
We postulate that some part of the cerebral side effects of Zn
supplementation are mediated by the mobilization of Cu from storage
in liver and muscle. With Zn by mouth the serum Cu may increase
for a period of one to three months before falling to a normal
level, With d-penicillamine therapy and Zn/Mn supplements this
does not occur. In some instances such as severe paranoia, or
retinal disease, the prompt decision to start therapy with d-penicillamine
plus Zn and Mn can be justified. The use of Zn and Mn with vitamin
B6 makes d-penicillamine therapy safe because as a chelator d-penicillamine
removes Cu, Zn and Mn. The loss of taste with d-penicillamine
is a sign of Zn deficiency.
Drug Flood Syndrome
Patients who come to the Princeton Brain Bio Center on large doses
of neuroleptics may get very sleepy when Zn and vitamin B6 are
used in treatment. This is the effect of the
neuroleptic on a brain made more normal and the dose of neuroleptic
should be rapidly reduced. For example, 40 mg of haloperidol can
be reduced to 5 to 10 mg at bedtime- The patient's affect improves
with the Zn and vitamin B6 so that the parents may suggest that
the neuroleptic dose is too large.
Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxine) Toxicity
An occasional patient will show high hair and high serum Zn levels
with elevated spermidine and low erythrocyte GOT activity. We
postulate that these patients have vitamin B6 deficiency and cannot
utilize the Zn present until adequate vitamin B6 is provided.
With vitamin B6 therapy the high Zn level drops to normal. Doses
of 1000 mg of vitamin B6 each morning are well tolerated but oral
vitamin B6 in doses of more than 2000 mg may produce tingling
or numbness of toes and fingers. This indicates the need for reduction
in the vitamin B6 dosages. With lower doses of vitamin B6 the
numbness is relieved.
The beneficial effect of Zn, Mn and vitamin B6 in pyroluria, is
important since this defect extends through many diagnostic categories.
The most urgent need is for daily supplements in those children
now labelled mentally retarded, learning disabled, minimal brain
damaged, autistic, dyslexic and hyperactive, For this purpose
some philanthropic foundation might wish to make available at
cost (or free of charge) a simple supplement consisting of the
daily need for Zn and Mn, namely 15 and 4 mg respectively plus
25 mg of pyridoxine (vitamin B6). The patients could be used as
their own controls and other vitamins could be used as placebo
medication for the first two weeks of medication while the basic
behavioral observations are being made
Signs of Zinc Deficiency
In order to diagnose Zn deficiency of the brain, peripheral signs
of Zn deficiency must be recognized. These are: white spotted
fingernails, cutaneous striae, nasal polyps, amennorhea, impotency,
tinnitus, abdominal pain, stuttering, poor dental enamel, loss
of taste, frequent infections, depression, insomnia, disperceptions
and hallucinations.
Signs of Zinc and Vitamin B6 Deficiency Zinc is needed for phosphorylation
of pyridoxal to make pyridoxal phosphate so adequate vitamin B6
should always be given with Zn. Patients without dream recall
are vitamin B6 deficient and vitamin B6 deficiency is the basic
nutrition deficit in Carpal Tunnel Syndrome and Chinese Restaurant
Syndrome (Folkers et al., 1981). Double deficiency of Zn and vitamin
B6, as in pyroluria, may cause the following: no dream recall,
sweet breath and body odor, morning nausea, crowded upper incisors,
splenic pain, pallor with itching in sunlight, constipation, achy
knees, amennorhea, impotency, seizures, disperceptions, hallucinations,
amnesia, paranoia, eosinophilia, lymphocytosis, high bilirubin,
and low immune globulin A (Pfeiffer, 1974). We have found a deficiency
of Zn and B6 in all girl families we have treated also.
Summary - Zinc in Schizophrenia
The mauve factor (kryptopyrrole) depletes patient of both Zn and
vitamin B6 (pyridoxine) because the pyrrole combines with pyridoxal
and then with Zn to produce a combined deficiency. These patients
suffer from "pyroluria", a familial disorder which occurs with
stress.
Pyroluria is treated by restoring the vitamin B6 and Zn so that
this double deficiency is corrected. A dose of vitamin B6 which
results in daily dream recall (a normal phenomenon) as well as
a Zn-Mn supplement are given daily. One should increase the daily
AM dose of vitamin B6 (up to 2-0 g/day) until dream recall occurs.
With Zn, Mn and vitamin B6 therapy the pyroluric patient may start
to respond in 24 hours and certainly some progress is noted within
one week. However, total recovery may take three to four months.
The biochemical imbalance and symptoms will usually recur within
one to two weeks if the nutritional program is stopped (Pfeiffer,
1974).
Pyroluria may occur together with other imbalances such as histapenia,
histadelia, high Cu or cerebral allergies and in these instances
progress will be slower. Low histamine patients are typically
overstimulated with thoughts racing through their minds making
normal ideation difficult, Low histamine children are hyperactive
while often healthy in other respects. Serum Cu levels in these
patients are abnormally high. Since Cu is a brain stimulant and
destroys histamine, the elevated serum (and presumably brain)
Cu level probably accounts for many symptoms, including the low
blood histamine level.
The treatment program consists of the administration of Zn, Mn,
vitamin C, niacin, vitamin B12, and folic acid. The rationale
underlying the treatment is that folic acid in conjunction with
vitamin B12 injections raises the blood histamine while lowering
the degree of symptomatology. Zinc and Mn allow for the normal
storage of histamine in both the basophils and the brain. With
this treatment the high blood Cu is slowly reduced and symptoms
are slowly relieved in several months time. Zinc and Mn with vitamin
C remove Cu from the tissues. The largest tissues of the body,
namely the liver and muscles, are flushed of their Cu first so
the serum Cu may rise to aggravate mental symptoms. If this occurs
then the dose of Zn should be reduced for a two week period. Excess
Cu may be acquired from commercial vitamins and minerals or drinking
water flowing through copper pipes. Distilled water may occasionally
be needed to reduce Cu intake.
David et al. (1976) found significant lead in the hyperactive
child but at a level less than that of lead poisoning. We find
similar levels of lead and high levels of Cu which is also a CNS
stimulant. We believe that with a high Cu level, any lead level
above the age of the child is suspect. These patients are also
Zn, and vitamin B6 deficient. With adequate Zn and vitamin C both
the lead and Cu levels return to normal within a period of six
months and the hyperactivity is decreased. These children frequently
have an elevated serum uric acid level which may indicate that
the heavy metals are adversely affecting the kidneys. Excess Cu
usually comes from the drinking water and lead exposure may be
from air pollution (traffic), contact with the printed page, etc.
Zinc deficiency occurs with faulty eating habits.
Epilogue
Nutrients at their best can be smart drugs that know exactly where
to go and what to do. In contrast, other drugs are non-specific
and go everywhere, with the molecules wandering aimlessly, producing
unwanted side actions. Nutrients at worst have no therapeutic
effect, and are either incorporated or excreted by the usual metabolic
disposal systems- Drugs at worst can be rapidly fatal or chronically
disabling, as in tardive dyskinesia. Nutrients are slow in relieving
symptoms, but when effective the relief is more permanent. Drugs
may have the impact of a bulldozer, so both the patient and the
therapist know that the drug is working. The slow onset of action
of nutrients makes rigid experimental design difficult. If the
patient is used as his own control, the placebo must then be given
initially rather than after the nutrient treatment.
The advantages of nutrient treatment are inherent in the accumulated
knowledge needed to use the nutrient. Usually a study of the patient
indicates that a specific defect might be present: sometimes this
can be assayed by objective tests. If these tests indicate a deficiency,
then the rigid statistical trials which are frequently applied
to therapy become meaningless. Scientists discovered the therapeutic
effect of the various B12 vitamins Without a double-blind test
because the objective tests were numerous and the biochemical
insight was extensive. We hope that such biochemical tests will
lead to better insight and treatment of the Schizophrenias. Biological
science can only give us progress reports: it is doubtful whether
the final word will ever be spoken or written in our slow conquest
of the schizophrenias.
References
Acknowledgements
This paper could not have been written without the expert help
of Elizabeth H. Jenney, M.S., Marie Arcaro, B.A., Eric Braverman,
B.S. and Barbara Aston, M.S., Nutritionist.
We acknowledge financial assistance from the following families:
Thomas Peters, Stephen Kahn, John Davenport and A.N. Spanel and
The Pine Level Foundation.