George D. OClock, Ph.D. (EE), P.E
Introduction
Hypertension is the most prevalent cardiovascular disease. Approximately
30 million Americans have been diagnosed with hypertension1 and
over 58 million Americans appear to be affected.2 Within certain
segments of the medical profession, blood pressure thresholds
and definitions for hypertension vary. Often, a systolic/diastolic
blood pressure of 140/90 mm Hg is used as a "borderline" to identify
the transition from an acceptable blood pressure level into the
realms of hypertension.3 For adults, borderline hypertension has
been defined as a systolic blood pressure range between 140 and
160 mmHg and/or a diastolic blood pressure range between 90 and
95 mmHg. Absolute hypertension occurs, once the 160/95 mmHg limits
have been exceeded.2
Background
The majority of people with hypertension have essential hypertension.
In their case, the high blood pressure condition does not have
an obvious cause.3,4 Cardiac rate and cardiac output increase
in some individuals with hypertension, but not all. However, an
increase in total vascular peripheral resistance is a common characteristic
of hypertension.
Experimental Procedure
Systolic/diastolic blood pressure and pulse rate were obtained
for a number of individuals over a three year period. One of the
individuals was a 58 year old male diagnosed with essential hypertension.
Initially, his average systolic/diastolic blood pressure was approximately
176/104 mm Hg with episodes exceeding 210/118 mm Hg during periods
of stress. Peak-to-peak systolic/diastolic blood pressure variations
throughout the day of 60/18 mm Hg were fairly common. An echocardiogram
revealed hypertrophy of the left ventricle. Records indicate that
this person had an untreated high blood pressure problem for almost
16 years.
After recording blood pressure data for nine months, this individual
accepted medication for his condition, initially involving a 5
mg/day dose of Vasotecª and ultimately a 20 mg/day dose of Zestrilª
(ACE inhibitors). After taking the initial Vasotecª prescription
for 8 days, his average blood pressure dropped to approximately
152/90 mm Hg with peak-to-peak variations decreasing to 30/10
mm Hg. Although further intervention was discussed, the hypertense
individual would not accept an increase in ACE inhibitor dosage
and would not accept any other form of medication (§-blockers,
calcium channel blockers or diuretics). This person preferred
to try other means of blood pressure reduction through diet, stress
control, exercise and nutritional supplementation.
There is some controversy concerning blood pressure variability
and the impact of various kinds of activities and stress on blood
pressure data. Part of this three year study involved recording
blood pressure variations that can occur with stress (job related
and family), eating, exercise, leisure time activities, relaxation,
and sexual activity for an individual who has hypertension.
The blood pressure-pulse rate data for the 58 year old male with
hypertension was compared with data obtained for a 48 year old
female, who was in good health, and a 17 year old high school
student who was in very good shape (actively engaged in swimming
and bicycling). The systolic and diastolic blood pressures vs.
pulse rate data for these individuals was plotted graphically
to detect any nonlinearities in their cardiovascular characteristics
and identify significant differences in the slopes of the individual
blood pressure vs. pulse rate characteristics.
From an orthomolecular medicine standpoint, the effect of various
nutritional supplements (vitamins, minerals, soy products, herbs)
on blood pressure and blood pressure variations is of significant
interest. One very interesting feature concerning the various
methods that lower blood pressure involves their combined (cumulative)
affect. Information on the ability of the various methods to lower
blood pressure in a coherent additive manner or a non-coherent
additive manner is very important from a treatment expectations
standpoint.
Finally, one topic that must be addressed involves the mechanisms
that might be associated with essential hypertension. This condition
may have a variety of causes.4 However, conventional physiological
and biochemical models have not been able to provide enough information
to clearly define a cause for this disease. Hypertension problems
are often attributed to some form of malfunction in the renal
system. In some cases, aberrations in kidney function can produce
inappropriate levels of renin secretion, higher levels of angiotenson
II production and increased aldosterone secretion. Essential hypertension
is often responsive to treatment with angiotension converting
enzyme (ACE) inhibitors. If this is the case, one might ask; "ÒAre
there other medical paradigms that might be considered so that
an Òobvious cause, associated with the renal system, can be provided
for some cases of essential hypertension?"
A possible link to one of the mechanisms of essential hypertension
could be associated with Dr. Björn Nordenströms theory of Biologically
Closed Electric Circuits (BCEC) and his description of Vascular-Interstitial
Closed Electric Circuits (VICC).5,6 Charge transport can occur
over VICC pathways because blood vessels can function as relatively
insulated cables providing a pathway for tissue fluids and moving
charges to reach the capillaries.7 After years of careful experimentation
and analysis, Dr. Nordenström developed a theory involving continuous
energy circulation and a corresponding electric/magnetic/electromagnetic
field circulation in living systems. Field circulation is accompanied
by the co-transport of charged species (ions and electrons) forming
continuous electric currents in the human body. These currents
are maintained within various BCEC pathways in the body involving
blood, interstial fluid, blood vessels, tissue, organs and neuromuscular
units. Dr. Nordenström realized that by augmenting various healing
processes normally associated with BCEC systems in the human body,
electrotherapeutic techniques could be developed to treat a variety
of diseases including cancer, neuromuscular disorders and cardiovascular
disease.
Dr. Björn Nordenström essentially "closed the loop" with respect
to electrical activity in living systems. He described a closed
system of adaptive electrical circulatory systems that maintain
and regulate various functions and promote healing processes.8
In his booklet, Hypertension Report,9 Dr. Julian Whitaker makes
a statement, regarding the treatment of hypertension with diuretics,
that blends quite well with Nordenströms BCEC theory. In the
booklet, he states: "Water alone is the best diuretic, so for
goodness sake, do your best to increase daily water consumption.
This approach increases urine production and replaces the need
for medication. Water allows the body to function at maximum efficiency
and supports the hydroelectric mineral salts that convey electrical
currents throughout the body."
From the standpoint of "convey[ing] electrical currents throughout
the body," Nordenström has measured endogenous electrical potential
differences and electric currents between tissues and vascular
components of the stomach, vena cava, aorta and left/right ureters
of an anesthetized pig.7 Current flow between organs was observed
for potential differences below 10 mV. Potential differences between
the ureters and veins were in the range of -106 mV to +112 mV
with VICC current levels of 1 µA to 15 µA.
Nordenströms results indicate that VICC systems can respond to
very small changes in energy state and they can be activated at
very low electric potentials. Therefore, in the absence of any
physical damage or biochemical aberrations, a hydroelectric imbalance
in the renal system could activate a number of mechanisms that
promote hypertension. For instance, changes in electric potential
can produce electric field variations that can have an effect
on the porosity of capillaries, the pH of various body fluids,
the movement of electrolytes and immune response.5 Capillary porosity
and electrolyte movement can be affected by changes in localized
electric fields. Therefore, the filtration process provided by
the glomerular capillaries of the kidney, along with mechanisms
associated with various renal clearance rates, could be affected
by the 10 mV to 100 mV variations in potentials that occur between
organs and various components of the renal system. In this case,
BCEC theory and the VICC model could be the basis of a new medical
paradigm that will help to explain some of the causes and mechanisms
associated with essential hypertension.
Results: Blood Pressure/Pulse Rate Characteristics
Systolic and diastolic blood pressure/pulse rate characteristics
for a 58 year old man with essential hypertension, a 48 year old
woman and a 17 year old high school student are shown in Figure
1a and Figure 1b (p.77). Several things stand out in these figures.
The systolic characteristic (curve (a)) for the individual with
hypertension shows a pronounced nonlinearity. The systolic characteristics
for the other two non-hypertensive individuals (curve (b)) are
on the same line. A portion of curve (a) and all of curve (b)
intersect at a systolic blood pressure of approximately 214.5
mm Hg at zero pulse rate. A mathematical equation involving systolic
blood pressure (BPs), pulse rate (PR), slope (ÆBPs/ÆPR) and standard
deviation (_s) can be derived from the data used to produce Figure
1 (a):
BPs = 214.5 mm Hg +(change BPs/change R)(PR) ± stand deviat.
(1)
For the systolic blood pressure curves of Figure 1a change BPs/change
PR is approximately 0.96 mm Hg/beats per min. and _s is approximately
9 mm Hg for the hypertensive individual and approximately 1.43
mm Hg/beats per min. and 5 mm Hg for the non-hypertensive individuals.
The higher systolic blood pressure levels for the hypertensive
individual are most likely due to variations in cardiac output.
The lower slope (change BPs/change PR) for the lower portion of
the hypertense individuals blood pressure characteristics would
tend to indicate that it is more difficult to promote increases
in cardiac output (cardiac rate X blood volume) as average blood
pressure increases. In this case, the arterial capacitance(Ca,
where Ca = change Volume/change Pressure) decreases at the higher
blood pressure levels because of limitations on volume increases
and elasticity with increased blood pressure.
The sharp increase in slope for the upper portion of the curve
could be indicative of an abnormality associated with increase
in arterial impedance. The arterial impedance increase at the
higher blood pressure levels could be due to the combination of
a reduction in arterial capacitance (which relates to elasticity)
and an increase in resistance due to stress and turbulent blood
flow. Certain forms of turbulence can be produced by large surges
of ejected blood from the hypertensive individuals enlarged left
ventricle. In addition, this nonlinear characteristic indicates
that for larger and larger increments of heart rate, the incremental
change in systolic blood pressure tends to decrease. This could
be indicative of the arterial capacitance variations that promote
orthostatic intolerance conditions sometimes associated with reno-vascular
hypertension and essential hypertension.10
In Figure 1b, curve (a) and curve (b) intersect at a pulse rate
of approximately 140 beats per minute at zero diastolic blood
pressure. A mathematical equation involving diastolic blood pressure
(BPd), pulse rate (PR), slope ( change BPd/ change PR) and standard
deviation ( stand deviat.d) can be derived from the data used
to produce Figure 1b.
BPd = (changeBPd/changePR)(140beats per min.-PR) ± stand deviat.
(2)
For the diastolic blood pressure curves of Figure 1b, change BPd/
changePR and _d are approximately 1.2 mm Hg/beats per min. and
9 mm Hg for the hypertensive individual and approximately 0.9
mm Hg/beats per min. and 4 mm Hg for the non-hypertensive individuals.
Slope comparisons associated with the diastolic characteristics
(changeBPd/changePR) of Figure 1b indicate a higher vascular peripheral
resistance for the hypertensive individual.
The hypertensive individuals hypertrophy condition has resulted
in a thicker left ventricle wall, and a reduced left ventricular
chamber volume. This condition, defined as concentric left ventricle
hypertrophy is most closely associated with hypertension and is
accompanied by an increase in total peripheral resistance.11 Generally,
a rise in total peripheral resistance increases the diastolic
blood pressure more than it increases the systolic. Increases
in cardiac output generally raise the systolic blood pressure
more than the diastolic.3
For situations where the hypertense individuals blood pressure
is increasing, the higher slope at high systolic blood pressures
could be indicative of a higher peripheral resistance along with
a higher cardiac output (cardiac rate). This resistance increase
could be due a number of interactive mechanisms including the
effects of turbulent blood flow. As previously mentioned, turbulence
can occur as a large volume of blood is forced out of the left
ventricle chamber by the enhanced contractions from a thicker
left ventricle wall. At lower blood pressures, the left ventricle
contractions would not be as forceful. This could contribute to
significant reductions in cardiac output and a reduction in turbulent
blood flow. The reduced turbulence would promote a more smooth
laminar blood flow and contribute to a lower peripheral resistance.
Blood Pressure Reduction Approach: Baseline Conditions and Initial
Therapeutic Approach
Blood pressure data was recorded daily for this person over a
three year time frame. Very pronounced cyclical variations were
measured on a daily, weekly and monthly basis, and a six month
cycle was also noticeable. The average (baseline) blood pressure
for the hypertensive individual was approximately 170/103 mm Hg
with very large blood pressure peak variations. After a full meal,
this individual could suffer incremental blood pressure increases
up to 45/20 mm Hg. In addition, incidences of family and work
related stress caused incremental blood pressure increases up
to 40/15 mm Hg. At times, blood pressure readings of 210/118 mm
Hg were observed at home, work and at the doctors office. During
periods of reduced work, summer vacations and work breaks; a consistent
decrease in incremental blood pressure was recorded. From this
data, it appears that the work environment contributes approximately
15/9 mm Hg to this individuals hypertension problem. However,
from the baseline data, it would appear that the work environment
is not the primary cause of this persons high blood pressure
problems.
As a first therapeutic step, the hypertense individual agreed
to take an ACE inhibitor (5 mg Vasotec initially, eventually progressing
to 25 mg of Zestril). He would not consent to taking any beta-blockers,
Calcium channel blockers or diuretics for his hypertension problem.
His average blood pressure decreased to 150/90 mm Hg, with significantly
lower blood pressure variations. Initially, some adverse effects
were noted (diarrhea and fatigue), and these symptoms subsided
after a week on the medication. Increasing the prescription by
50% produced an additional reduction in systolic blood pressure
of approximately 7 mm Hg. However, the increased intake of the
drug caused a significant increase in fatigue along with coordination
problems, dizzy spells and depression. At this point, it was clear
that the primary approach toward blood pressure control could
have its share of health hazards if it was based on drug therapy
alone.
Blood Pressure Reduction: From an Orthomolecular Medicine Approach
The initial approach toward blood pressure control involved diet.
A lower intake of fat and processed sugar produced a blood pressure
incremental decrease of 15/6 mm Hg over a period of three weeks.
However, blood pressure variations remained high. One of the simplest
and most effective therapeutic approaches involved the combination
of a significantly higher water intake, and supplementation with
lecithin (3600 mg/day) and L-carnitine (500 mg/day). Increasing
water intake can help to promote a better hydroelectric and sodium-potassium
balance in the renal system. Lecithin (phosphatidyl choline) will
promote the synthesis of acetylcholine, a neurotransmitter that
tends to reduce blood pressure. L-carnitine is important in the
oxidation of fatty acids and is sometimes described as an oral
chelating agent. As Figure 2 (p.101) indicates, the combination
of these three substances promoted an incremental blood pressure
reduction of 16/8 mm Hg over a period of twelve days. One of the
interesting characteristics associated with this approach involves
a three day lag before any noticeable response is observed. The
hypertense individual also noticed that the nocturnal reduction
in systolic and diastolic blood pressure began to return. Prior
to this, his blood pressure was often higher in the morning than
it was the evening before. In addition, previous to this, systolic
blood pressure incremental increases were often quite high (greater
than or equal to 45 mm Hg) after eating a full meal. After the
water/lecithin/L-carnitine combination was implemented, incremental
increases in systolic blood pressure were significantly lower
(less than or equal to 25 mm Hg) after eating a full meal.
In many cases, exercise and weight lifting (in moderation) are
recommended for blood pressure control. This particular hypertense
individual tried a number of exercise programs and found them
to be beneficial in a number of areas (including energy and ability
to sleep), but very little reduction in blood pressure was observed
with exercise. In fact, often, when he was exercising the most,
these were the time periods when his average blood pressure readings
were at their higher levels.
A soy product called raffinee-a produced a response similar to
the one observed with the water/lecithin/L-carnitine combination.
Taking two vials per day of this nutritional supplement produced
a
12/7 mm Hg incremental decrease in blood pressure (Figure 3, p.102).
What is interesting about this nutritional supplement is that
no response was observed for approximately 3 days. Several other
individuals, who were not taking medication for hypertension saw
significant reductions in blood pressure. In one instance, a 64
year old male recorded a decrease in blood pressure from 140/90
mm Hg to 120/70 mm Hg taking three vials of raffinee-a each day.
A variety of supplements were taken in order to promote cardiovascular
conditioning and reduce blood pressure. These supplements included
beta carotene (20,000 IU/day), Ca/Mg (600/300 mg/day), vitamin
B complex, niacin (300 mg/day), flaxseed oil 500 mg/day), coenzyme
Q10 (60 mg/day), zinc picolinate (30 mg/day), ginko biloba (100
mg/day), bilberry extract (250 mg/day), horse chestnut extract
(400 mg/day) and potassium (100 mg/day). The most pronounced effect
observed with this combination was a 10 mm Hg reduction in diastolic
blood pressure (indicating a reduction in total peripheral resistance).
There was no significant reduction in systolic blood pressure
(indicating a minimal effect on cardiac rate or blood volume).
Also, no additional decrease in diastolic blood pressure was observed
for this individual when these supplements were increased.
Another factor in blood pressure control involves the reduction
of cholesterol and triglycerides. A number of nutritional supplements
were taken each day by the individual with hypertension in an
attempt to reduce his total cholesterol level (223 mg/dL) and
triglyceride level (208 mg/dL). The list of supplements included
cayenne pepper (40,000 HU), omega 3 fish oil (500 mg), vitamin
C (1000 mg), L-carnitine (500 mg), pycnogenol (100 mg), vitamin
E (800 IU), L-lysine (500 mg), garlic (400 mg), selenium (200
mcg), inositol (150 mg), licorice root and L-arginine (100 mg).
Within a year, his cholesterol level decreased to 177 mg/dL and
his triglyceride level decreased to 131 mg/dL. The cholesterol
and triglyceride reduction did not seem to produce significant
reductions in average blood pressure levels. However, some reduction
in day-to-day incremental blood pressure variations was observed
over that time frame.
In the analysis of the various items that increase and decrease
blood pressure; the three year study strongly indicates that one
must be very careful not to utilize coherent addition in the analytical
approach. For instance, assume a certain supplemental herb, by
itself, reduces systolic blood pressure by 10 mm Hg. Assume another
nutritional supplement, by itself, also reduces systolic blood
pressure by 10 mm Hg. When the two supplements are combined, the
total reduction in systolic blood pressure will not be 20 mm Hg.
In this case, the process of non-coherent addition is more applicable.
When the two supplements are combined, the total reduction in
systolic blood pressure will be closer to 14 mm Hg, ie. ((102
+102)H mm Hg= 14.14 mm Hg). Combining substances that reduce blood
pressure does produce a cumulative effect. However, under the
constraints of non-coherent addition, the substances that have
the smaller effects do not accumulate as efficiently as one would
expect when they are combined with substances that produce more
pronounced reductions in blood pressure.
Conclusions
Blood pressure reduction for individuals with hypertension is
strategically important not only for cardiovascular health, but
also from the standpoint of minimizing kidney damage. However,
blood pressure medications appear to have their own complications
and dangers. Certain diuretics can deplete potassium and magnesium
levels and increase cholesterol and triglyceride levels. They
can cause digestive stress, muscle spasms, problems with renal
dysfunction and aplastic anemia along with increasing the risk
of heart attack and cardiac arrhythmias.12,13 Beta-blockers can
promote impotence, fatigue, depression and congestive heart failure
in susceptible patients.12,14 Calcium channel blockers can weaken
the heart and damage the liver.12,14 Adverse consequences associated
with ACE inhibitors are generally not quite as severe as those
associated with other medications. In fact some improvement with
insulin sensitivity in patients with insulin resistance and some
cholesterol reduction may occur in patients with certain renal
diseases.14 However, the attempt to go off the ACE inhibitor can
produce a very significant rebound effect. In this case, the blood
pressure goes to a higher level than it was previously. Clearly,
alternative forms of blood pressure control are desirable, especially
from a long-term standpoint.
Often, diet and control of the work environment will be recommended
as primary therapeutic approaches toward the treatment of high
blood pressure. The results of this three year study on hypertension
indicate that focusing on a recommendation like this may not be
the best approach for some people afflicted with hypertension.
In most cases, blood pressure problems have underlying physiological
reasons, and the physiological deficiencies must be corrected.
For older people, there are usually a large number of interactive
deficiencies that must be addressed.
The hypertense individual in this 3 year study has a number of
inter-related health problems that are contributing to his high
blood pressure condition. First of all, based on his responses,
he is obviously dehydrated. This is a very common problem in many
older people and is often the root cause for a variety of health
problems ranging from cardiovascular disease to lower back pain.9
Referring to Whitakers statement and Nordenströms BCEC/VICC
model of the renal/vascular system, deficiencies in the bodys
hydroelectric system can promote aberrations in the electric potentials
between various VICC components (ureters, blood vessels, other
organs). Small variations in these potentials can have a significant
influence in filtration processes, electrolyte balance and renal
clearance rates. This model appears to be appropriate for the
essential hypertension condition, and it would appear that, for
many individuals, water intake is one of the first primary items
to address for the treatment of essential hypertension. Electrical
imbalances in the renal system could contribute to a hypertension
problem that eventually damages the renal system, which will produce
additional complications for the high blood pressure condition.
Along with increased water intake, it would also appear that essential
hypertension problems could be addressed by recommending a certain
amount of lecithin and L-carnitine supplementation. L-carnitine
is biosynthesized in the liver. Any decreased liver function,
often associated with aging processes, could require supplementation
of this amino acid.
The second primary item to be addressed involves the high diastolic
blood pressure levels. The cardiovascular system is under the
influence of the diastolic pressure for most of the cardiac cycle.
The total peripheral resistance is indicated by the diastolic
pressure, and diastolic pressures of 104 mm Hg to 118 mm Hg are
unacceptable. Nutritional supplementation included vitamin A,
Ca/Mg, vitamin B complex, niacin, flaxseed oil, coenzyme Q10,
zinc picolinate, ginko biloba, bilberry extract, horse chestnut,
potassium and raffinee-a would appear to be the next step in the
therapeutic process to reduce total peripheral resistance and
help to promote renal system electrolyte balance.
The third item is partially addressed in the first two items.
It involves long-term remediation of cholesterol and triglyc-erides
contributing to overall cardiovascular health and the minimization
of extremes in blood pressure incremental variations. Once cardiovascular
and renal health problems have been addressed, appropriate, safe
and realistic exercise and work environment control programs can
be incorporated.
Acknowledgements
The author wishes to thank Professor Björn Nordenström and Carl
Firley, President and North American Vice President of the International
Association for Biologically Closed Electric Circuts in Biomedicine
(IABC) for their helpful comments and suggestions. Additional
discussions with Dr. Steve Mercurio, Department of Biological
Sciences, Mankato State University, Mankato, MN and Michael B.
Rath, MD, Mankato Clinic, Mankato, MN are also gratefully acknowledged.
References