Stephen A, Barrie, N.D.; Jonathan V. Wright, M.D.; Joseph E. Pizzorno,
N.D.
Abstract
The effect of oral ingestion of garlic oil was studied in 20 healthy
human volunteers in a double-blind, two period, cross-over trial,
The individuals were randomly divided into two groups. Each group
rotated for four week periods through 2 different sequences of
oral supplementation including: 18 mg of garlic oil (extracted
from 9 grams of fresh garlic) and placebo, The amount of platelet
aggregation decreased significantly (p < .005) during garlic administration.
Serum cholesterol levels and mean blood pressure both decreased
significantly (p<.011, p<.009) during garlic supplementation.
Serum high density lipoprotein levels rose significantly p.< .001)
during garlic administration. There was a significant rise in
arachidonic acid in red cell phospholipids following garlic administration.
The results of this study (the first double-blind, crossover study)
suggest that garlic has therapeutic potential as an anti-atherosclerotic,
antithrombotic and anti-hypertensive agent in normal healthy adults.
Garlic, known botanically as Album sativum, is a widely distributed
common plant. It is used in all parts of the world not only as
a spice and food, but also as a popular folk remedy for a variety
of ailments. Its importance had been recognized several thousand
years ago in China, India and Egypt. In 1944 the essential oil,
believed to be the active ingredient, was distilled out and named
Allicin.1 There recently has been renewed research in the therapeutic
uses of garlic. Hypolipidemic2-13, platelet aggregation inhibition14-18,
antiatherosclerotic 1O-24 fibrinolytic enhancement 25,26, antibacterial
and anti-fungal 27 properties have all been reported.
Atherosclerosis and coronary artery disease remain the number
one killers in civilized countries of the world. It is now recognized
that hyperlipidema is associated with increased incidence of premature
ischemic heart disease.28 Hypercholesterolemia correlates highly
with the risk of myocardial infarction.29 Elevated high density
lipoprotein (HDL) levels may exert a protective effect against
coronary artery disease30. Due to the previously reported positive
effect of garlic on these blood components in unblinded tests
on animals and humans, this study was designed to test some of
these parameters in a controlled doubleblinded study with normal
human volunteers.
Methods
Twenty student volunteers, average 26 years of age, enrolled in
the project. All completed informed consent letters and the project
was approved by the Human Subjects Review Committee of the College.
All were in good health and showed no signs of degenerative cardiovascular
disease. Each person was given a list of drugs that affected platelet
aggregation and was asked to avoid these during the trial. Individuals
were also asked to limit dietary garlic. No other dietary restrictions
were imposed. The design of the acuity was a double-blind, two-period
crossover trial. The individuals were randomly divided into 2
groups.
Each group rotated through the following four-week supplementation
periods: 18 mg of cold pressed garlic oil (extracted from 9 g
of fresh garlic) per day; and placebo. The active regime perles
also contained 158 mg coconut oil, 30 mg glycerin and 54 mg gelatin.
The placebo perles contained 160 mg coconut oil, 30 mg glycerin
and 54 mg gelatin. The placebo perle bottles (containing 60 capsules)
were laced with 500 mcg of garlic oil. Both the active and placebo
bottles had strong garlic odors. There was a three week wash-out
period between each four week supplementation period during which
no capsules were taken, Capsules were taken with meals, The supplements
were formulated and coded by General Nutrition Research Laboratories,
Fargo, North Dakota.
Platelet aggregation percentages, serum lipid levels and blood
pressure readings were measured before and after each supplementation
period. Fasting (6 h) blood samples were obtained by venipuncture
from the antecubetal fossa using a Wee vacutainer (BD 6430).
Five cc of blood were transferred to a plastic tube containing
3.8% sodium citrate, incubated at 370C for 30 no and then spun
at slow speed, with 500 ul extracted as platelet rich sample;
the remainder was spun at high speed for platelet poor sample.
Using a Chronolog Aggregometer (#430) and an experimental Chronolog
Whole Blood Aggregometer for comparison, agglutination times were
measured after exposure to ADP.31
The remaining 5 cc of blood was allowed to clot and then spun
at high speed with the serum being removed and subject to direct
quantitative colorimetric determination of total and HDL cholesterol
levels using the modified Lieberman-Burchard reaction procedures32
and a Baush & Lomb Spectomic 21 spectrophotometer. Individual
mean bilateral sitting brachial blood pressures were measured
by an experienced technician after each blood sample was drawn.
Participants were asked to refrain from any strenuous exercise
for 4 It prior to sampling. Paired t tests for pairs and class
were used to identify statistically significant differences between
mean values of changes and differences in change, Students t test
was calculated using the computer program 'Statistical Package
for the Social Sciences'.
Results
Cholesterol, HDL, mean blood pressure levels and platelet aggregation
percent after supplementation with placebo and with garlic are
presented in Table 1. During garlic administration, platelet aggregation
was reduced significantly, by 16.4% (p <.005) as compared to no
significant change during placebo administration (between classes
with no cross-over).
Figure 1 illustrates the change in mean cholesterol levels during
the two different supplementation periods. Mean serum cholesterol
levels dropped significantly (from 195 to 180 mg/ 100 ml, p <.001)
during garlic administration. There was a slight insignificant
drop during placebo trial. The difference in change during the
garlic versus placebo administration was also significant (12.5
mg/ 100 ml, p <.01).
Results from HDL measurements are presented in Figure 2. Mean
HDL levels rose significantly during garlic supplementation (from
56 to 69 mill 100ml, p < .001). The difference in change between
the two periods was also significant (8.3 mg/ 100m], p < .01).
There was an insignificant rise in the HDL levels during placebo
trial. Figure 3 shows the mean blood pressure measurements during
each period. Levels dropped significantly during garlic administration
(94 to 88 mm FIG, p < .009). The difference in change between
the two supplementation periods was also significant (3 mm FIG,
p <.07). There was a small insignificant drop during placebo trial.
Discussion
Garlic contains an essential oil, allicin (C6H1OS20), which contains
allylpropyl-disulphide diallyldisulphide and several other sulphur
compounds. The active principal of garlic appears to be the essential
oil. The concentration of essential oil in garlic is 0.3 to 0.
0.4%.In our study garlic administration has led to significant
decreases in platelet aggregation, serum cholesterol, mean blood
pressure as well as a significant rise in serum HDL's in normal
healthy humans when compared to placebo supplementation. Due to
the odoriferous nature of garlic oil, no double blind studies
have been previously reported. We feel a measure of the success
of our novel 'blinding' is the small, but insignificant placebo
changes in the same direction as the active trial.
Previous work by Makheja et al.33 has shown garlic extract to
inhibit platelet aggregation in vitro. The results of their work
indicate that garlic almost completely suppresses thromboxane
B2 synthesis. Further results indicate that garlic inhibits platelet
aggregation by alterations in both the platelet cyclooxygenase
and lipooxygenase pathway. Studies by Ariga et al. 34 have isolated
this component as methyl allyl trisulphide (MATS) which is a minor
component in garlic oil. Bordia17 has shown that in vitro platelet
aggregation was markedly inhibited in a dose-related manner when
human blood was exposed to garlic oil. Bordia has also shown that
oral administration of 25 mgs of garlic for 5 days significantly
inhibited platelet aggregation in humans and may inhibit some
aspects of thrombus formation. Boullin35 has reported that eating
10 grams of garlic cloves significantly inhibited platelet aggregation
in 3 human volunteers. Work by Apitz-Castro et al.36 suggests
that garlic's inhibitory effect might be mediated through modification
of the physiochemical properties of the plasma membrane, rather
than by affecting the arachichidonic or calcium metabolism of
platelets.
We also measured the full range of fatty acids in plasma, and
red blood cell total phospholipids were measured in order to,
monitor the possibility that garlic might affect levels of polyunsaturated
fatty acids known to influence platelet aggregation. There were
no significant changes in plasma or red cell fatty acids in the
placebo group or in plasma fatty acids in the garlic group. There
was however, a significant rise in arachidonic acid in red cell
phospholipids following garlic administration. This might be consistent
with reduced conversion of arachidonic acid to thromboxane A2,
a mechanism of garlic action which has been proposed elsewhere.
This study provides the first support for these previous findings
in healthy adults using a controlled double-blind two-period crossover
trial. Previous research examining the effect of garlic on blood
lipids in rats, rabbits and humans has been extensive. In cholesterol
fed rats, Chi et al.2 found that garlic feeding increased the
excretion of neutral and acidic steroids and exerted a hypocholesterolemic
effect, Kamanna et al.9 showed that garlic perles produced a significant
decrease in serum and liver cholesterol levels in rats fed an
atherogenic diet. Interestingly, Kamanna compared and calculated
the efficacy of garlic perles (containing the volatile oil) as
being 6 times greater than that of garlic powder. Jain and Konar8
demonstrated similar results when they fed rabbits an atherogenic
diet and observed that garlic oil decreased tissue cholesterol
and minimized atheromatous changes in the rabbit aorta. They hypothesize
that the low ester cholesterol (EC) value found in the garlic-
fed rabbits contributed to the low EC that was found in the vessel
intima. Bordia and his coworkers7 suggest that the protective
action of garlic against induced atherosclerosis in rabbits is
due to several factors; the restriction of the rise in blood cholesterol
and lipids; the minimization of the fall in alpha lipoproteins;
and the increased fibrinolytic activity of plasma. In humans,
the effect of garlic has been studied in induced alimentary hyperlipidemia,
in hypercholesterolemic persons, and in normals. In two separate
studies, Bordia and co-workers4, 10 showed that the essential
oil of garlic can prevent the harmful effects of fatty meals on
humans by preventing the fall in fibrinolytic activity, the rise
in serum triglycerides and the rise in the platelet adhesive index
normally associated with this type of diet. Bordia13 also found
that in healthy humans fed garlic for six months, serum cholesterol
and trigyclerides were reduced and HDL levels raised. Augusti5
hypothesizes that these effects of garlic may be due to allicin
lowering the amount of reduced NAD and NADP in the body, Allicin
can combine with SH groups, the functional part of CoA, a necessary
part of the biosynthesis of cholesterol. The effect of raw garlic
on normal blood cholesterol in humans was studied by Bhusan et
al.37 They found that blood levels decreased significantly in
all the participants after two months of garlic ingestion.
Our results parallel those studies reported above. Serum cholesterol
levels (initial range from 130 to 270 mg / 100 ml) were lowered.
and HDL levels (initial range 41 to 94 mg/100 ml) were raised
significantly in humans during our blinded trail.
Using spontaneously hypertensive rats, Foushee and Ruffin38 have
reported that 0.5 ml/kg of garlic oil lowered the systolic blood
pressure to a normal level and sustained the decrease for up to
24 It, We have found that administration of garlic oil to normotensive
humans (mean blood pressure range from 88 to 108 man HG) for four
weeks significantly reduced the mean blood pressure.
TABLE 1.Effect of garlic and placebo on serum cholesterol, serum HDL, mean blood pressure and platelet aggregation.

The results of this study suggest that garlic oil could be an
effective therapeutic agent, as part of a regime for the control
and prevention of atherosclerosis and coronary artery disease
in humans due to the observed lowering of cholesterol, blood pressure
and platelet aggregation. More work still needs to be done in
order to better understand its methods of actions.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Ray Suen, Director, Meridian Valley Laboratories
for his invaluable technical assistance. We would also like to
thank Dr. M.S. Manku and Nancy Morsa of EFAMOL Research Laboratories
for the EFA analysis.
References